First thing I do is check to is if there is a short between any of the pins.
There are many factors that go into choosing a FET for a particular application. On resistance, off resistance, max peak current, max steady state current, max voltage, gate charge and others. If you have to replace a FET with a different one all these have to be taken into consideration. That requires an understanding of why that particular component was chosen. "Better" values might lead to unintended consequences.