That was about the Fluke 28(-II I think), basically a ruggized version of the Fluke 87-V, I don't think the 87 would have survived all that. Plus I don't think I've ever abused a multimeter (including Flukes) that way, I don't think I've even dropped one from bench height. In my opinion, being able to survive a dunking or three meter drop is useful in some industrial environment, eg. when working on lighting or HVAC, but not really for hobby use. If you need that type of multimeter, what are you going to do for soldering iron, power supply or function generator?
It's quite possible that there are flaws that are not apparent from the datasheet, like long term stability, but the datasheet is all we have without the real thing. I would check Dave's review for any issues with the U1253A not relating to the OLED display, I don't think he though the build quality was inferior to Fluke. Many design features are likely to be similar between the U124x and U125x series. Keep in mind that we're comparing a brand new Agilent meter with warranty to a used Fluke with no warranty and which may even have defects (though it likely works fine). I would trust Agilent as a brand, but would worry that it's a re-branded item manufactured by someone like Rigol, like many of their other low-end products. These are usually much lower quality with less support than the real Agilent products.
Unfortunately long term stability is something I can't really test, so I've just gotta go with a gut feel based on the construction and components, the company/design group history etc. I'd love to have a proper thermal chamber to at least do some thermal cycles for example, but I don't have access to one any more I'm afraid.
I've actually heard something bad about the "A" model Agilents and how they would drift over the long term (1 year+), and that's why they have changed to the Orange "B" series on all their models to secretly fix it. I don't know how true this is though, my meter has no problems so far and I have heard not heard any other bad news.
I like the Agilent meter, it's pretty good. Not as well designed and made as the Fluke's, but still pretty good.
Agilent were supposed to send me B version of the 1253 and 1242, but internal changes meant I lost my contact. I might have to get onto them again once the backlog of current gear is gone.
Although their meters are designed by the old Escort design group in Malaysia they bought, Agilent will stand by their gear and would have pretty tight control over their processes, so that's a big positive.
If I had $200 to spend on a new meter I'd probably get the Agilent.
0.09%, 10000 count, cal certificate and report, and the Agilent badge for $200 is a pretty good deal I think.
The Extech 530 would be a big competitor at $200 and 0.06% 40,000 count.
Dave.