While the Canon 750D DSLR alone will cost 550 JDs! everyone here seems to agree that camcorders are far better than DSLRs, so according to them this Sony HDR-CX455 is better solution overall.
No, as always, "it depends".
be honest with me, is there any other feature (needed for electronics videos as you know) that this camcorder lacks?
The HDRCX455 has front mounted mics, not ideal for behind the camera commentary. Doesn't matter if you use an external mic of course.
I use internal mic for all my behind the camera work just for convenience.
I also don't think it has a proper audio VU meter, and it lacks lots of control buttons.
This is basically just a low end toy comsumer camcorder.
They are OK, but not great.
If you had to make me pick from those two, I'd actually chose the DSLR and just deal with the small things.
You can't and shouldn't just buy any camcorder because it's a camcorder.
I will use the external mic of course, so audio will be good enough. Having audio VU meter wasn't in my required features and since using an external mic (that connects to my shirt, I guess audio will be good regardless of the meter.
What I really liked about it is the video quality. It supports up to 1080p 60fps video and with 64 gb memory card, it will be awesome. It said that it has touch screen and all options are there using buttons... so yeah I guess it is nice.
Dave, you don't know my budget. Your say it is a toy and these camcorders are ok but not great according to your standards since you have way more budget than me without any comparison. However, my salary is about 400 JDs so this camcorder is about the limit of my capabilities.
Camcorder (Sony HDR CX455) + memory card (64gb) + BOYA BY-M1 microphone + usb desktop mic + company payment (shipping + handling + customs + their fees) = ~550 JDs.
While that Canon 750D DSLR alone is 550 JDs locally!
not to mention I need to buy tripod and its extension (for overhead shots) = around 110 JDs. + a cheap white LED light = 10 JDs.
I hope you know my reality and why that particular camcorder is about nearly the best option to have, unless you know a better suggestion with the same price tag which is the center point of all this.
____
Looking at that (not with my usual studio monitor speakers) I'd say you don't need any new equipment, it will not instantly make your videos any better.
Your image quality is fine, just get rid of the camera shack (presumably due to mounting on the same unstable desk you are using).
You can make a successful channel with the equipment you have now, no question.
I personally don't like the "top down" camera look, but that's me.
Things like framing and changing camera angles for different shots as required is much more important than having better image quality because you used a DSLR.
What about my previous English content?
The problem was the very few views I get, but sometimes I get good views like my episode 15 video. However other videos are just frozen due to the bad filming. I cannot do much with Nexus 4 smartphone as there are no specialized equipment to help. That shaky video due to cheap stick which does not stick properly. Proper tripod and its extension will cost around 110 JDs... but they do not accept smartphones.
My biggest concern now is the language. I am a native Arabic speaker and sometimes I get the idea to change the channel to Arabic due to bad quality of available content overall except for Walid Issa videos which are not top of the line too.
However, I also see some kinda acceptance to my English videos. Some of them are still getting views till now (regularly). So what to do?
Getting new equipment will greatly help me since I can do these shots you talked about. However, I need to decide what to do about language. I explained earlier about the type of content that I have in mind for now... dunno what you think about it.
Greatscott is successful because of several things, none of which really involve equipment:
- His cool German accent and enthusiasm
- His careful choice of camera angles and shots
- His deliberate use of (almost entirely?) voice-over audio in the editing phase. (It's much easier to get better and more consistent audio when you are doing voice-overs then when behind the camera recording "live" like me)
- Short sharp transitions and pacing
- His very careful limiting of speech and omission of detail to keep videos short and to appeal to a broader audience than other electronics channels.
- Consistent video production timeline
- Well chosen themes, titles and thumbnails to appeal to a mass audience.
- Deliberate choice of topic (like hacking stuff) that appeals to a larger audience than electronics tutorials. If he stuck to just electronics tutorial he'd probably only have 1/10th the audience he does, that's just the nature of the market.
In short, his production and editing values are what makes the difference, not his camera or equipment.
Yes, but he uses a good camera not Nexus 4!! he cannot achieve that using a smartphone.
About voice-over, actually he inspired me to do it since I won't be charismatic speaker in English. Here is my best video overall:
What do you think about it?
I got 2.9K views last 28 days, +1K alone from that video... and I don't even know why?!!
While this video below is far much better in nearly all terms, and does not get views:
I can do such content as greatscot and afromod (voice over thing), but again, I need proper camera and tools.I added a 30$ usb desktop microphone to be able to record on my laptop since I do suffer recording on smartphone with bad quality.
reaching that level of production is not impossible but it depends on time (since tools are available). However, I am living very far and don't have access to buy all these components to test and do stuff with them like he has. I live in a shared room with one guy so I don't have all the time I need to record. I do have little space (like 3 meters wide) and table as my working area.
I need your advise to know what is better for me, to continue making videos in English? or Arabic?
I use your theme of "EEVblog #100 - blah" naming -> "VEGEteK #010 - blah" so I wonder if it is good or should I remove naming?
The other thing camcorders have is better battery systems. The batteries stick out the back and you can get massive extended battery packs that not only last for an entire days shooting but are also easy to change without taking the camera off the tripod.
I could not live without my long life battery pack camcorder, it would drive me insane.
My shoots are often many hours long and involve shooting 100+ clips, it's essential for me to have a battery that lasts all day.
Also, most DSLR's cannot shoot any length video, they overheat, so will often limit you to like 20min clips. That's no good for interviews or long single take clips for example. Just something to be aware of.
Yeah but 20 mins are too short. I won't keep recording for hours but certainly will hit 30 minutes.
As I said earlier, seems like HDR CX455 is the best choice overall.