Definitely a convection toaster oven for even temperature, plus a PID controller (from Omega engineering if you want it to just work reliably, or ebay if you want it cheaper) and a SSR for switching the elements. Since you're in 120V land, rewire the heater elements in series so they would be in a nominal 240V configuration, so you'd drop the power to 1/4 of original or just disconnect some if you only need 1/2 power, etc.
If you get a PID controller with an auto tune feature, let it tune itself with a medium-small size chunk of metal inside to let it have some thermal mass to tune to, but not an excessive amount.
Make sure to keep thermal fusing and normal fusing in place.
I use an omega temp controller, +SSR to control a heater for a snake terrarium, and with the output on a 1s period (No need for slower, as there are no mechanical contacts to preserve) it stays within 1degree F all the time. Just had to let it auto-tune for an hour or two before adding stuff to the inside of the tank.