EEVblog Electronics Community Forum

Electronics => Projects, Designs, and Technical Stuff => Topic started by: zlymex on February 16, 2015, 05:00:57 pm

Title: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: zlymex on February 16, 2015, 05:00:57 pm
1. Why Switch/Scanner
Comparison of standard(voltage/resistor) is precise, repeatable, low Thermal EMF.
Comparison can be easily made automatic.
Multi-reading results make statistics/averaging at ease and achieve high confident level.
Standards to be compared may be relatively permanently connected thus inconsistency due to contact variation is greatly reduced.
May compare multi-standard(ex. up to 16 or greater) for a long time.
Derived use i.e. measurement of temp-co.
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136522)

2. Why DIY powerless Switch/Scanner
Very simple to use. No programming, no GPIB.
Powerless, and therefore no direct interference from the mains.
Powerless, and therefore very little heat generated and less Thermal EMF.
Compact, low cost.
No power switch, consume virtually no power when idle.
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136524)
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Resistor Stand
Post by: zlymex on February 16, 2015, 05:05:28 pm
3. Features and Principles of the DIY switch
Provide 2*2(DPDT) or 4*2(4PDT) switch, or 2*4, 4*4, 2*8, 4*8, 2*16, 4*16 switch.
MC control(Multi-meter Measurement Complete Signal).
MC power supply, consume about only 0.3mA current.
Use 74HC CMOS and related low power IC.
Use Latching relay to achieve low power consumption.
Manual switch and free running mode provided.
Operates in loop manner only.

MC or VMC signal is usually provided by precision multimeters as a standard feature.
It usually stay logic high when idle or during measurement, and goes to logic low briefly when a measurement is complete.
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136526)
When measurement by the multimeter is complete, it's the perfect time for switch/scanner to operate.

Newer multimeters use CMOS IC for VM output thus the high level is nearly 5V. Old ones such as my Agilent 3458A (made in 2006) uses TTL IC which gives only 3.65V when drawing 0.5mA current. However, this is enough for the switch to operate properly.

Although is mechanical, the relay will complete it's switch over in less than 5ms, plus settle down of the measured V or R, which normally within the default delay time of a typical multimeter. For 3458A 10V range NPLC=50, default delay is 10ms. This delay may be increased if needed.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Resistor Stand
Post by: zlymex on February 16, 2015, 05:10:54 pm
4. Schematic of My first 4*2 switch for two standards(V or R) comparisons
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136542)

The Latching relay, Omron G5AK-237P
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136544)
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136546)
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136548)
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136550)

Omron G5AK-237P, DPDT low signal double-winding latching relay.
Data sheet is here http://datasheet.octopart.com/G5A-237P-DC5-Omron-datasheet-109999.pdf (http://datasheet.octopart.com/G5A-237P-DC5-Omron-datasheet-109999.pdf)


The Drive
Normally the set or reset coil operate at 5V individually.
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136552)

However, the set and reset coils are identical and can be connect in series or in parallel. When in series, it also operate at 5V but consume half the current.
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136554)

When paralleled. it will operate at 2.5V but the current will be doubled. This is the way I use.
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136556)


Power supply
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136558)
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136560)

I use HT7136 low dropout CMOS low power regulator. Connect a 200 Ohm resistor and a Schottky diode to VM, and output is 3.5V minimum through the use of a 470uF filter capacitor.
DS of HT7136 is here: http://www.holtek.com/pdf/consumer/71xx_1v170.pdf (http://www.holtek.com/pdf/consumer/71xx_1v170.pdf)

The Principle is straight forward, every time a measurement is complete, VM goes low briefly toggle the J-K flip-flop and hence the relay.
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136562)

Optional trigger is also provided for manual momentarily switch K or by activating the free running astable vibrator.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Resistor Stand
Post by: zlymex on February 16, 2015, 05:18:09 pm
5. Implementation and testing
Breadboarding first
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136564)

Then assemble the device on universal board
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136566)
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136568)
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136570)

Cat. 5 twisted pair, pure copper and screened, good for this purpose.
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136572)
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136578)
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136574)
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136576)

Test is performed by making measurements of two inputs alternatively
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136580)

Sampling is done by another DIY interface device:
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136582)
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136584)
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136586)

One end of the device is connect to multimeter GPIB, another end is connect to PC's USB port by a RS232-USB converter(early version) or direct USB connection(later version). This device is designed by llycom and is widely used among Chinese volt-nuts.

By running the dedicated program, one can send any GPIB command to the multimeter.
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136588)
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136590)
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136592)

It also provides a precision temperature sensor(DS18B20).

The final graph is the test result when two inputs shorted. Ideally the dark blue line and purple line should be equally flat to zero but it's not owing to multimeter's noise and offset. However, the average of the two lines are quite the same with less than 5nV difference, well below the noise level of 3458A.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Resistor Stand
Post by: zlymex on February 16, 2015, 05:26:13 pm
6. Next version of the 2*4 switch

First 8 photos show the implementation of PCB version by Mytek, last 4 photos show the miniature version.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Resistor Stand
Post by: zlymex on February 16, 2015, 05:29:38 pm
7. 17*2 scanner for up to 17 voltage standards comparisons
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Resistor Stand
Post by: zlymex on February 16, 2015, 05:34:33 pm
8. 16*4 scanner for 4 wire standard resistors comparisons

believe or not, 32 latching relays and it's related circuitry power by multimeter VM and consume as little as 0.2mA (When 3458A choose NPLC=50 and AZ on)

Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Resistor Stand
Post by: zlymex on February 16, 2015, 05:39:19 pm
9. Application examples

By applying very stable 100mA current thr two one-ohm resistors, 3458A reads two 100mV alternatively thus will compare to sub-ppm level.
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136677)

Compare two 10V.
Blue line: 3458A measurement of a 10V standard (Warming up curve)
Red line: difference of two 10V standard plus 10V.
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136675)

Standard resistors comparison chart and photo.
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136679;image)
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136681;image)

For those who can view 38hot.com properly, I have other scanner related topics:
Mechanical switch http://bbs.38hot.net/thread-1006-1-1.html (http://bbs.38hot.net/thread-1006-1-1.html)
Overview of metrology scanners http://bbs.38hot.net/thread-1016-1-1.html (http://bbs.38hot.net/thread-1016-1-1.html)
Data Proof 160A Scanner, Principle and modification http://bbs.38hot.net/thread-1082-1-1.html (http://bbs.38hot.net/thread-1082-1-1.html)
DIY 16ch Powerless Scanner for Voltage http://bbs.38hot.net/thread-3658-1-1.html (http://bbs.38hot.net/thread-3658-1-1.html)
DIY 16ch*4wire Powerless Scanner for Standard Resistor Comparisons  http://bbs.38hot.net/thread-4041-1-1.html (http://bbs.38hot.net/thread-4041-1-1.html)
Precise measurement of alpha/beta temp-co of SR104 standard resistor http://bbs.38hot.net/thread-1352-1-1.html (http://bbs.38hot.net/thread-1352-1-1.html)
DIY 100mA constant current source for comparison of 1 ohm standard resistor http://bbs.38hot.net/thread-17593-1-1.html (http://bbs.38hot.net/thread-17593-1-1.html)
Tests on 7V and 10V voltage standards http://bbs.38hot.net/thread-645-1-1.html (http://bbs.38hot.net/thread-645-1-1.html)


<The End>
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: quarks on February 16, 2015, 08:06:49 pm
Great work, thanks a lot for sharing :-+

Here is one of my scanner cards for Keithley 7001 with very nice COTO relays (see att. pic.)

on Reply #2 unfortunately I cannot see your pictures
edit: now it is the same on other replys also

on Reply #3 Where did you get the spade lugs?

on Reply #7 SR104-1, 742A + VHP101 look flat as expected, but what is the jump 11y/2W?

Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: zlymex on February 16, 2015, 09:43:49 pm
Thanks quarks, that's is a very good switch board. My approach is to generate less heat to compensate not-so-good relays.

Reply #2 I see the photos fine, both reply #2 and others.

Reply #3 those spade lugs was a custom made group-buy in China, pure copper, later I changed to lugs with gold flashed.

Great work, thanks a lot for sharing :-+

Here is one of my scanner cards for Keithley 7001 with very nice COTO relays (see att. pic.)

on Reply #2 unfortunately I cannot see your pictures
edit: now it is the same on other replys also

on Reply #3 Where did you get the spade lugs?

on Reply #7 SR104-1, 742A + VHP101 look flat as expected, but what is the jump 11y/2W?
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: quarks on February 16, 2015, 09:57:09 pm
Hello zlymex,

here is what I see (see att. pic.)
(http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/diy-low-thermal-emf-switchscanner-for-comparisons-of-voltage-and-resistor-stand/?action=dlattach;attach=136720)

Those spade lugs look very good. Is it possible to buy some?
They would be a great addition to my
http://www.eevblog.com/forum/buysellwanted/diy-low-emf-cable-and-connectors/msg190302/#msg190302 (http://www.eevblog.com/forum/buysellwanted/diy-low-emf-cable-and-connectors/msg190302/#msg190302)
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: zlymex on February 16, 2015, 10:08:58 pm
Hello zlymex,

here is what I see (see att. pic.)

Those spade lugs look very good. Is it possible to buy some?
They would be a great addition to my
http://www.eevblog.com/forum/buysellwanted/diy-low-emf-cable-and-connectors/msg190302/#msg190302 (http://www.eevblog.com/forum/buysellwanted/diy-low-emf-cable-and-connectors/msg190302/#msg190302)

I see your reply pictures fine, but I don't know why my pics won't show up on your side.

Those spade lugs was bought 5 years ago and I was a group buy participant. Usually the seller will be long gone.

lly/2w is the DIY two-wire  standard resistor by llycom sent to me for test. I cannot recall what's inside as I did not open it for photo. I guess it's a single VHP101-10k.
Because it's two wire, there is a value jump when I disattach and reattach the lugs from the binding post during test.

btw, My VHP101 DIY consist of 4 matched resistor elements.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: quarks on February 16, 2015, 10:11:10 pm
now I know it is IE, because with Operea I can see your pictures (still wonder what the cause is)

btw, My VHP101 DIY consist of 4 matched resistor elements.
Very nice!!!
Have you used 4x 10k values (2 in series and than same in parallel) or did you use 4x 40k in parallel?
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: zlymex on February 16, 2015, 10:22:39 pm
now I know it is IE, because with Oprea I can see your pictures (still wonder what the cause is)

btw, My VHP101 DIY consist of 4 matched resistor elements.
Very nice!!!
Have you used 10k values (2 in series and than 2 parallel) or did you use 4x 40k in parallel?
Here is the large photo with resistor values on it, 9k999.
Mine is 4 wire(actually it's 6 wire), but llycom's 2 wire.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: zlymex on February 16, 2015, 10:34:39 pm
Talking about matched resistors, I selected the 4 from a batch of 40.

2 resistors may match alpha temp-co, it usually takes 4 to match beta as well.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: quarks on February 16, 2015, 10:36:00 pm
Here is the large photo with resistor values on it, 9k999.

thanks again

Your board looks like ceramic. Can you share some details?
When I did some home work for a "as good as possible" DIY resistor reference, I bought some ceramic solder stands (see att. pic.).
I hope with this stands, it will be possible to also build high resistance values (I plan 1GOhm). Have you tried high resistance values also?
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: zlymex on February 16, 2015, 11:39:37 pm

thanks again

Your board looks like ceramic. Can you share some details?
When I did some home work for a "as good as possible" DIY resistor reference, I bought some ceramic solder stands (see att. pic.).
I hope with this stands, it will be possible to also build high resistance values (I plan 1GOhm). Have you tried high resistance values also?
Ceramic solder stands is a very good idea as I bought some as well.
I use Teflon board in hope it's better insulation. However IMO, ceramic is good enough for 10k even for sub-ppm level requirement.
For higher resistor value such as 1GOhm, still good if precision not exceed 0.01% and keep the surface dry and clean.
I tried even higher values like 10GOhm and 100GOhm, guarding must be applied even the insulation is Teflon.
What resistor element you plan to use for 1GOhm?
I once use 100 Dale RN55D 10MOhm for 1G.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: quarks on February 17, 2015, 12:06:48 am
I use Teflon board in hope it's better insulation.

thanks, that makes it much easier to drill the holes

However IMO, ceramic is good enough for 10k even for sub-ppm level requirement.
For higher resistor value such as 1GOhm, still good if precision not exceed 0.01% and keep the surface dry and clean.

good to know

I tried even higher values like 10GOhm and 100GOhm, guarding must be applied even the insulation is Teflon.
What resistor element you plan to use for 1GOhm?
I once use 100 Dale RN55D 10MOhm for 1G.
Yes, guarding is a must for high resistance values (att. are some details from Keithley Low Level Meas. Handbook)

Until now I have bought OHMITE MOX 500MOhm (but only 1%), several Caddock USF 0.01% (but only 10MOhm, which will be extremly expensiv when I need 100 pieces) and I have a sufficient large batch of promissing Caddock MG745 40MOhm 0.1% on order.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: zlymex on February 17, 2015, 01:03:52 am
until now I have bought OHMITE MOX 500MOhm (but only 1%), several Caddock USF 0.01% (but only 10MOhm, which will be extremly expensiv when I need 100 pieces) and I have a sufficient large batch of promissing Caddock MG745 40MOhm 0.1% on order.
That's great :-+
While I cannot find Caddock USF(or cannot afford), I bought 100+ used Caddock TF020R-3 20MOhm instead.

Another expensive option for 1G or 10G maybe Supper MOX(MOX910)

Your blue Omite is Mini-Mox, I also bought 20+ similar Slim-Mox 104 500MOhm for 1G and 10G.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: quarks on February 17, 2015, 02:02:18 am
Super MOX 910 looks also good

do you know by chance what is used in the Fluke 8508A-7000K calibration kit (see att. pic.)?
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: Vgkid on February 17, 2015, 03:00:45 am
Well done.
This will be a rather interesting thread to follow.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: quarks on February 17, 2015, 03:14:19 am
OT: I indeed normally do not use IE with my private PCs.
But with my business PCs I am forced to use it, so sometimes I open eevblog with IE
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: Mickle T. on February 17, 2015, 04:51:29 am
This idea has been widely used in the Prema DMMs. I used a similar scheme to control the sealed relay (RPS-25) in the selfcal module of the 8.5-dig. DVM.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: Andreas on February 17, 2015, 07:17:47 am
Hello Lymex,

thanks for sharing also from my side.

There are many good ideas in the cirquits.
Especially using the DMM trigger as power supply was a fact that
I could not see from the link on volt nuts to 38hot.com.

8. 16*4 scanner for 4 wire standard resistors comparisons

believe or not, 32 latching relays and it's related circuitry power by multimeter VM and consume as little as 0.2mA (When 3458A choose NPLC=50 and AZ on)
I guess it is only for resistors and not for reference voltages.
Or do you have a possibility to get into some "reset" state for the relays after "power on".

The bad news is that Mouser is saying that the OMROM G5AK-237P is "discontinued"  :(  ...

But the good news is that I found an alternative relay, the Panasonic TX-S series  :) ::

I am using Panasonic/Matsushita TQ2 series (the TN2 series would work also) running for about 1-2 weeks from a 9V block including microprocessor.

With best regards

Andreas

Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: splin on February 18, 2015, 03:03:54 am
The bad news is that Mouser is saying that the OMROM G5AK-237P is "discontinued"  :(  ...

But the good news is that I found an alternative relay, the Panasonic TX-S series  :) ::

I am using Panasonic/Matsushita TQ2 series (the TN2 series would work also) running for about 1-2 weeks from a 9V block including microprocessor.

With best regards

Andreas

Panasonic specify a minimum switching load of 10uA, 10mV which might be a problem for comparing references - but probably not for a few thousand or 10s of thousands cycles! They recommend the SX series for low signal levels but even those specify a minimum of 10uA, 1mV.

I know that they ran into this problem at a company I used to work for - minimum loads aren't always quoted for relays but some contact materials rely on the current disruption to clean the contacts.

I wonder if the contacts get noisy over time or just suffer increasing contact resistance?

Are reed relays better in these regards being hermetically sealed?

The thermal EMF spec is for the TXQ is 5uV and .3uV for the TX-S but those are for the non-latching parts. Are you using latching versions and if so have you measured the thermal EMFs (or tried - I guess it's quite tricky to do)?

Thanks,  Splin
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: Vgkid on February 18, 2015, 04:19:35 am
What about switching a resistor to ground previous to making the measurement. Or as part of a self test sending a current through all of the relays.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: Andreas on February 18, 2015, 08:33:44 am

The thermal EMF spec is for the TXQ is 5uV and .3uV for the TX-S but those are for the non-latching parts. Are you using latching versions and if so have you measured the thermal EMFs (or tried - I guess it's quite tricky to do)?

Hello,

I use the TQ2-L2-5V version (the latching type). Otherwise a 1-2 week operation would not be possible from a 9V block.
picture is here: http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/lm399-based-10-v-reference/msg567203/#msg567203 (http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/lm399-based-10-v-reference/msg567203/#msg567203)

I am not able to measure thermal EMFs reliable since my 24-Bit ADC is quite noisy. (1uVpp with a integration time of 1 minute).
A partly compensation of the thermal EMFs is done in my setup since I am doing a offset measurement through the relays.
I can actually switch the +/- signal of the output to every + pin of the references or to the common ground. So its possible to do difference measurements between 2 references also.

Some cleaning of the contacts is also done by daily switching of the relays.

With best regards

Andreas
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: quarks on February 19, 2015, 01:40:00 am
finally received the Caddock MG745 40MOhm 0.1% resistors.
In my first checks they are well within spec and spread positive and negative in value.
That should help in combining them to a my specific values.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: timb on February 19, 2015, 02:01:03 am
Wow, thanks so much for this thread! I'm working on a scanner myself and it never occurred to me I could do it self powered!


Sent from my Tablet
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: timb on February 20, 2015, 06:48:30 pm
By the way, these might be a nice stand-in for those Omron relays: http://www.mouser.com/ProductDetail/TE-Connectivity-Axicom/V23079B1201B301/

$3/ea, 5V, DPDT 2-coil bistable in through hole. According to the datasheet thermal emf is <10uV, which is as good as the baseline version of the Coto Low Thermal relays (much better I imagine though as they are latching so no internal heat generation).


Sent from my Tablet
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: 3roomlab on December 01, 2015, 06:45:36 pm
wow this is a good thread for DIY !
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: Gyro on December 01, 2015, 11:13:27 pm
It would be prudent to stock up on Mercury wetted bistable reed relays for this kind of use while they are still available on ebay / surplus market.

They're the only contact technology capable of truly dry switching, and with stable contact resistance and a cycle life long enough to never have to worry about.

Edit: ...and of course zero bounce.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: branadic on December 06, 2016, 06:32:44 am
The scanner of the Prema 5017 SC uses Omron G6AK-234P, just for the info. The scanner is specified with thermo forces typ. ±1µV, max. ±2 µV after 1,5 h warm-up. The Prema 2080 scanner, that I had, is specified the same way using the same relays.

http://ohh.de/5017.htm (http://ohh.de/5017.htm)
http://ohh.de/2080.htm (http://ohh.de/2080.htm)
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: Mickle T. on December 06, 2016, 06:50:09 am
Prema has a nice and bulky series 2000 of precision scanners. The top MUX 2010, that I had, have a max 50 nV of thermo forces.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: branadic on December 07, 2016, 05:11:21 am
Prema has a nice and bulky series 2000 of precision scanners. The top MUX 2010, that I had, have a max 50 nV of thermo forces.

Never heard of that model, the only info I found is the manuel:

http://www.prema.com/index.php/de/service/messgeraetewartung/item/download/116_124e71e4309f5edffbaa2bfc370ef7b5 (http://www.prema.com/index.php/de/service/messgeraetewartung/item/download/116_124e71e4309f5edffbaa2bfc370ef7b5)

Smells like a teardown and a lot more photos of your unit, cause less then 50nV (measured on the plugs) is very interesting for the volt nuts here :)
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: dr.diesel on December 07, 2016, 05:16:42 am
Smells like a teardown and a lot more photos of your unit, cause less then 50nV (measured on the plugs) is very interesting for the volt nuts here :)

And another saved eBay search!
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: doktor pyta on December 05, 2017, 10:56:18 am
Inspired by Zlymex, I started to design my own scanner based on the same idea.
The goal is to make some improvements:

1. indicate active channel's number (1 of 16 LEDs). The measurements are made very slowly.
       If there is some bad connection etc. it will be easy to identify.
       I tested green LEDs that work satisfactory biased with 50uA of current.
2. provide Manual control of the channel
3. provide power-on reset (quite tricky part...)
4. use RJ45 connectors, so the user just cuts off-the-shelf CAT6 cable in two pieces and strips wires only on one side.
      This also makes testing of relays easy - just disconnect RJ45 cables and plug in RJ45 plugs with pairs shorted by loop of wire.
      The RJ45 connectors will be hidden inside metal enclosure to ensure thermal equilibrium.
5. use SMD components (prepared to reflow soldering, better EMF performance expected)
6. the board should fit standard TUFxx Fischer Elektronik enclosure
7. It's nice to have a spare relay on board (tribute to Data Proof scaners)
8. the design should be expandable to 2 wire 32 channels; 4 wire 16 channels; 4 wire 32 channels by using the same boards (with some PCB jumpers, desoldering of some components but basically same design)
9. last but not least: the scanner shall provide break-before-make action not to disturb expensive gear and save the relays.


The quiz is: Open the schematic pdf file and find as many bugs as possible.
If anyone is interested in factory made PCB for this project let me know ->PM.
Zlymex has a free PCB if he wants ;)
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: beanflying on December 05, 2017, 01:22:44 pm
Interested! Weighing up another 6 1/2 - 7 1/2 Meter or a 34970A and boards.  :)
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: doktor pyta on December 05, 2017, 10:30:58 pm
First bug found: net NE0 added to J5 connector.
Without it the slave board would not break-before-make.
Schematic upgraded to rev 0.2

Edit:
SW1 pin 6 connected to wrong node.
Schematic upgraded to rev 0.3

Edit: Switched from 74HC4538 to 74HC123 for two reasons:
4538 has built-in power-on reset circuit which would disable generation of a pulse after turning scanner on. This is not wanted in this circuit.
4538 draws much more idle current.
Schematic upgraded to rev 0.4
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: beanflying on December 08, 2017, 12:20:17 pm
Now Interested for interests sake. Santa is bringing me an Agilent Box  8)
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: cellularmitosis on March 29, 2018, 03:25:41 pm
Heyo,

I've been thinking about scanner switching arrangements.

What I'd like:


Here's what I've come up with (attached).

You can't compare any Vref against any other Vref: they are separated into two groups, and any Vref from group "A" can be compared to one from group "B".

With this restriction, you can get away with only two DPDT relays per Vref, which is pretty cheap.

Here, four Vrefs are shown, but the idea is that any number of Vrefs is supported.

The DMM also uses two SPDT relays and can do the following:


Just to walk through some examples:

To measure Vref 1:


To measure Vref 2:


To measure Vref 1 against Vref 2:


Edit: the caps on each Vref are large enough that they can be switched from SUPPLY to BATTERY A/B without losing power.  This is a somewhat simplified schematic, as there would probably a regulator after each capacitor, keeping a stable voltage supplied to each Vref.

Edit 2: to elaborate, Vrefs 1, 3, ... are in group "A" and Vrefs 2, 4, ... are in group "B".  So you can measure Vref 1 against 2 or 4, but not against 3.  To get the difference between 1 and 3, you'd have to do it indirectly by measuring 1-2 and 3-2, then calculate 2-3.  With a large number of Vrefs, many cross-checks are possible, so errors in the system should become apparent.

Edit 3: the batteries can be charged, but all Vrefs must be on SUPPLY, so no (floating) measurements can take place while the batteries are being charged.

Edit 4: I wonder if this thread should be moved to metrology?
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: cellularmitosis on March 29, 2018, 04:00:38 pm
doktor pyta, I no longer see the pdf of your schematic, was it removed from your post?
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: doktor pyta on March 30, 2018, 05:26:39 am
Hi cellularmitosis,

it was weird situation when only I was attending my own quiz of searching for bugs  :)
Besides the thread was filled with schematics which all contained bugs.

You will find rev1.0 schematic in the attachment.
Take a look on the list of operation modes.
*I don't know if anyone ever will use 8 wire mode but it is also available.

EDIT: new file loaded: operation mode table improved for clarity.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: Echo88 on March 30, 2018, 08:39:44 am
Dont tell me that scanner-mainframe you just bought with the load of 20-relay-cards dont suffice cellularmitosis  :-DD
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: cellularmitosis on March 30, 2018, 08:46:37 am
Dont tell me that scanner-mainframe you just bought with the load of 20-relay-cards dont suffice cellularmitosis  :-DD

The scanner gets me started immediately with something that works, but does no good for the community!  Ideally I can produce some smaller scanner kits, benchmark them against the Keithley cards with the COTO relays, and publish an open source design to help out fellow volt nuts :)

Buying old gear is nice, but reproducing equivalent results in a DIY project is a lot more satisfying :)
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: Echo88 on March 31, 2018, 10:51:35 pm
Hmm, since my old Keithley 7064 card produces unstable readings in some configurations i would be interested in some new cards. The easiest solution for me would be designing keithley 705-compatible cards (defined lengths and a 15pin-card-edge-connector), but then i have the problem that they were build to drive non-latching relays and i would have to add drive logic on the cards to use latching-relays. Meh.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: cellularmitosis on April 30, 2018, 02:09:06 pm
Just whipped up a tiny board for a single resistor which uses machine-pin headers for a pluggable 4-wire connection.  It has multiple footprints, so it will accept a vishay foil, a wirewound, etc.

Now, to design a scanning motherboard to plug them into...

https://github.com/pepaslabs/resistor-plug

https://oshpark.com/shared_projects/hp93BAlQ

Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: splin on May 02, 2018, 12:07:07 am
Just whipped up a tiny board for a single resistor which uses machine-pin headers for a pluggable 4-wire connection.  It has multiple footprints, so it will accept a vishay foil, a wirewound, etc.

It would be better to have the sense connections next to each other to minimise any temperature difference and thermal EMFs.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: dr.diesel on May 03, 2018, 10:28:27 pm
Dont tell me that scanner-mainframe you just bought with the load of 20-relay-cards dont suffice cellularmitosis  :-DD

The scanner gets me started immediately with something that works, but does no good for the community!  Ideally I can produce some smaller scanner kits, benchmark them against the Keithley cards with the COTO relays, and publish an open source design to help out fellow volt nuts :)

Buying old gear is nice, but reproducing equivalent results in a DIY project is a lot more satisfying :)

An open low thermal scanner would be a great community asset.   :-+

I'll offer my Data Proof 160 (still unproven, but works) for benchmark as well.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: doktor pyta on May 21, 2018, 10:01:08 am
Update. Try to find a typo (engraving company fault  :palm:)
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: 2N3055 on May 21, 2018, 04:28:10 pm
Update. Try to find a typo (engraving company fault  :palm:)

C'mon, what's a two CH16 between friends...  ?     :-DD



Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: doktor pyta on June 04, 2018, 07:02:55 am
Some photos showing details of RFS135B.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: doktor pyta on June 04, 2018, 07:04:17 am
++
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: doktor pyta on June 04, 2018, 07:05:13 am
Just before putting into enclosure.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: branadic on June 05, 2018, 02:38:21 am
Time to measure the performance like thermal emf :) Nice build.

-branadic-
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: 2N3055 on June 05, 2018, 06:45:06 am
I'm making doktor pyta scanner too.. Two boards for a 16ch/4W scanner config..
All parts are here and ready. Time to get busy.

Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: 2N3055 on June 17, 2018, 07:21:14 am
After few evenings of soldering i assembled scanner..
It has two boards, so I can do 4 wire x 16 channels..

All parts were easily ordered from TME and Farnell.
Boards are good quality, switching part with relays is isolation routed form rest of board..
Power consumption is very low, so no problem for DMM logic output to drive it...

Now I need to make cables. 
Will be testing it with my 7562 Yokogawa (I'm waiting for a connector for Yokogawa, it doesn't use BNC) and Rigol DM3068.
I will also do some timing testing to see what are parameter boundaries..

Regards,

Sinisa
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: cellularmitosis on June 17, 2018, 09:19:11 am
Very cool!  Where did you order the kit?
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: plesa on June 17, 2018, 05:08:38 pm
RJ45 is OK for low EMF scanner? What type you have?
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: 2N3055 on June 17, 2018, 05:41:38 pm
It's not really a kit. It's Doktor pyta scanner from above, I just got PCBS , and front and back panels for a standard Hammond box from him. His schematic is above in this topic..
Regards,
Sinisa
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: 2N3055 on June 17, 2018, 06:06:13 pm
Hi Plesa, long time no hear...

Yeah, it looks too easy, but...

That connector is very compact, and isothermal by virtue of that, it is shielded (also acting metal thermal spreader on the outside). Contacts are very close, made of gold plated beryllium copper, very low thermal mass, attached directly to board, being isothermal there... Also SFTP cable is twisted pairs, pure copper, individually shielded with aluminium, that acts as shield and thermal spreader...

Generally, doktor pyta went with making everything as isothermal and low mass as it can be, instead of relying on exotic components. We shall see how well it does, but in his measurements so far, he got double digits nV TEMF..
I don't have equipment at the moment to measure whatever TEMF it makes now.. My crystal ball sees more equipment in my future... Nanovoltmeter would be nice....:-)

What these connectors are not is that they are not low leakage and are SELV only (max 60V)...
I would think it cannot be used for precision measurement of 100 Gohm with 500V..

My use for this scanner is measuring voltage refs (up to 20V), 4W resistor comparisons (up to 10Mohms), and 4W PT100/1000 and precision thermistor measurements. It should do this with less influence than 6.5 digit DMM can see.
That is more than OK for me now..

Of course, I will keep you guys posted.

Regards,

Sinisa

P.S. This is the connector type..

Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: 2N3055 on June 18, 2018, 05:01:02 am
I did a little test, scanner works with voltages of more than 4,5 V and low going pulses from longer than cca 950 nsecs.

So 4.5V and up and more than 1 usec pulse going low works reliably.

When I make cables I will also measure brake-before-make interval too...

Regards,

Sinisa
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: doktor pyta on June 18, 2018, 05:46:25 am
Hi Sinisa,

few observations after some time of operation:

1. if You change D1  (BAS86) to eg. LL41 You may reduce minimum operating voltage by approx. 200mV.
2. as I warned before custom cable must be prepared. This is due to wire allocation in standard Ethernet cable (see RJ45 ethernet cable pair drawings in google)
3. Power-On-Reset is weak point of the design. It allows to charge capacitors and turns on channel 1. The problem is that You never know which channel remained active at the end of previous operation cycle. The best ad hoc solution after powering is to press NEXT button for 16 or 32 times to make sure all relays are in known position.
4. current revision of  the schematics below.
Title: Re: DIY Low Thermal EMF Switch/Scanner for Comparisons of Voltage and Res. Standard
Post by: 2N3055 on June 18, 2018, 06:14:33 am
Hi Sinisa,

few observations after some time of operation:

1. if You change D1  (BAS86) to eg. LL41 You may reduce minimum operating voltage by approx. 200mV.
2. as I warned before custom cable must be prepared. This is due to wire allocation in standard Ethernet cable (see RJ45 ethernet cable pair drawings in google)
3. Power-On-Reset is weak point of the design. It allows to charge capacitors and turns on channel 1. The problem is that You never know which channel remained active at previous operation cycle. The best ad hoc solution after powering is to press NEXT button for 16 or 32 times to make sure all relays are in known position.

1. Yes, of course..
2. Yes, I didn't mention this. Cables are not made as standard ethernet cables, were pairs are intermixed. Here pairs are in PAIRS, so cables have to be crimped 1-2  3-4  5-6  7-8 .. That's why you have to make them otherwise I would just cut few ethernet cables in half.
3. I did notice that from schematic. I also went for a scan through channels once on startup and then reset.... Not a problem for now. I have some ideas how to work around that . I'll let you know...

Thanks for your help..

Regards,

Sinisa