1
General Technical Chat / Re: Do you think an LED is a resistor?
« Last post by Gyro on Today at 04:14:55 pm »This is getting nobody anywhere...
In the real world, semiconductors, including diodes (of all flavors) have datasheets. These specify the typical and worst case voltage / current characteristics under defined conditions. People find these USEFUL in designing them into circuits and products in the real world. Your dogmatic semantic argument that they are all resistors is NOT USEFUL in the real world. See the distinction?
Your dinner tonight will have electrical resistance, which will be determined by its composition temperature etc. as will the plate it is sitting on, the table they are sitting on, the chair you are sitting on (and the arse you're sitting on it with). Will you sit there making semantic arguments that they should all be defined as resistors until it gets cold (or in your case possibly moldy), or in the real world, will you just eat it?
In the real world, semiconductors, including diodes (of all flavors) have datasheets. These specify the typical and worst case voltage / current characteristics under defined conditions. People find these USEFUL in designing them into circuits and products in the real world. Your dogmatic semantic argument that they are all resistors is NOT USEFUL in the real world. See the distinction?
Your dinner tonight will have electrical resistance, which will be determined by its composition temperature etc. as will the plate it is sitting on, the table they are sitting on, the chair you are sitting on (and the arse you're sitting on it with). Will you sit there making semantic arguments that they should all be defined as resistors until it gets cold (or in your case possibly moldy), or in the real world, will you just eat it?