Looking for a better utility knife

[ataradov]

I'm looking for a utility knife that takes blades like shown below. I want to find one that has the blade attached firmly. Most (all) hardware store type knives have lots of wiggle in the blade, which makes them unusable for reasonably fine work.

I don't mind if replacing the blade is not done by a slider, but requires a few screws.

Any recommendations?

[Ian.M]

Over here we call them stanley knives, as they were originally made by an American company 'The Stanley Works'.   An all metal fixed blade genuine Stanley knife is hard to beat though it helps considerably if you use genuine blades (many of the cheap clone blades are significantly thinner) and shim the blade holder with thin waxed (or lightly oiled) card so there is absolutely no slop.  An older used one in good condition may be preferable to what's found new in the big box DIY stores.

[TechItApart]

How about this?

http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B003I85GT6/ref=mp_s_a_1_1?qid=1453840232&sr=8-1&pi=SY200_QL40&keywords=milwaukee+knife&dpPl=1&dpID=31mVtp-nsGL&ref=plSrch

I've got a CK tools one which is very similar. Great to use.

[Bud]

I have one of these Milwaukee folding knives, I like it better than the Stanley one in general but in terms of blade wiggle it is not any better than Stanley. For fine work/PCB I use an Olfa snap-off knife

http://www.olfa.com/products-snap-off-blade-utility-knives/

[Monkeh]

Real Stanley knives are about as good for wiggle as you're likely to get. Fixed rather than retracting may be less wiggly.

If you want something for fine work, invest in www.amazon.com/dp/B00002X201 or something similar.

[steverino]

If I remember correctly,  a drywall knife will use that blade and it won't wobble.  The blade does not retract however.  Home Depot (US) use to carry them in the drywall tool section. 

edit..  Here it is...

[sleemanj]

unusable for reasonably fine work.

Wrong tool for the job surely.  Fine work = scalpel / x-acto knife style.

[Lukas]

I can really recommend this one: http://www.gerbergear.com/Activity/Work/Knives/EAB-Pocket-Knife_22-41830 Doesn't wobble and looks kinda nice.

[KJDS]

I either use a scalpel for fine stuff or an old kitchen knife for bigger things.

Stanley's are for carpets and plasterboard.

[ataradov]

I can really recommend this one: ... Doesn't wobble and looks kinda nice.

Well, I ordered Milwaukee one (along with some other stuff) from Amazon. And one of the things in my cart was an Add-on item, so I had to reach certain total price limit. I was a bit short, so I looked around what else looks nice. And I added exactly this knife

[KL27x]

Stanley's are for carpets and plasterboard.

Good for leather, too. Anywhere you need to push the entire blade through a thick and stiff material.

But it's not a huge amount of jobs that can't be done as well or better with a $5.00 2-3" pocket knife. At least at a bench where you can resharpen when needed. I used to buy razor and exacto blades in bulk; 100 packs. Then one day I ran out and resharpened an exacto. Huh, whadya, know, it worked and was faster than changing the blade.

It's been many years since I had a boxcutter. I still use an exacto on occasion. But there are definitely a huge variety of bladed tools for any job which are purposely shaped for specific jobs and will last a lifetime. Instead of buying replacement blades for each one, you can keep a basic set of tools for shaping/sharpening them all. With a grinder and/or belt sander you can modify or make tools for specific jobs, even.

[ataradov]

I can really recommend this one:

That Gerber knife is basically what I was looking for.

Now there is a question. It comes with a blade that is about 2 times thicker than your typical hardware store blades. I can imagine any other knife will perform well with this type of blade. How do I identify them? As far as I can see, thickness is never specified, it is always marketing BS like "Heavy Duty" and such.