Author Topic: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.  (Read 33416 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline broderpTopic starter

  • Regular Contributor
  • *
  • Posts: 64
  • Country: us
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #25 on: April 22, 2015, 12:49:17 am »
Mine is scheduled to arrive tomorrow.    :clap:

Crazy UPS shipping routes shipped it from PA, to Columbus OH, then right past my home in the Dayton area to Indianapolis IN.......   :wtf:  So now I wait for it to travel back east to me, hopefully by tomorrow as scheduled.

Oh do I know what you mean.  I live in Columbus.  my DSA815-TG made to Columbus to be delivered,  then for some unknow UPS screwed up logic.  it went to Indianapolis then back for delivery the next day.  and we wonder why rates go up.   8 hours of unneeded travel time is why.

 ;D ;D ;D  So true!

I got my supply today.  This thing is HEAVY!  It has a quality feel and very nice to the touch.  I'm very impressed.  :-+  Powered up, and thanks to Dave's video's I'm working it like a pro! (Well sort of... ::) )

A few details if anyone cares about the current stock from TEquipment:
-Calibration-November 29th, 2014
-Newest version with large silver heat sink  :-+
-Firmware/Digital version: 00.01.11


Only a few issues (non-issues really)

1. They should at least ship this with one or two sets of leads- I knew this, but am coming up short leads to play around with this tonight!
2. They should supply a printed full manual and not just the quick guide-but..I've already printed the manual, in full color on works laser printer and bound it)
3. Better software for USB to PC control-haven't used it yet, but not expecting much

So far so good.  I'm really wanting the precision upgrade and am now fighting the urge to just buy it.  :-\

 

Offline kjdotts

  • Contributor
  • Posts: 35
  • Country: us
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #26 on: April 22, 2015, 02:40:05 am »
I got my supply today...

Looks like we both received units from the same TEquipment.NET batch. Your unit should have the new TopBoard_V02.20 (as pictured here) and new BottomBoard_V02.20 (my unit has both). I performed a complete teardown (to tidy up the wiring and tweak a few quality control related issues) after thoroughly testing and burning in my unit for several days.

-Kris
 

Offline broderpTopic starter

  • Regular Contributor
  • *
  • Posts: 64
  • Country: us
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #27 on: April 22, 2015, 04:39:34 pm »
I got my supply today...

Looks like we both received units from the same TEquipment.NET batch. Your unit should have the new TopBoard_V02.20 (as pictured here) and new BottomBoard_V02.20 (my unit has both). I performed a complete teardown (to tidy up the wiring and tweak a few quality control related issues) after thoroughly testing and burning in my unit for several days.

-Kris

I noticed I only received 2 spare fuses, the documents stated 3.  Are they counting the one in the unit?

I also noticed we don't have the latest firmware.  (00.01.13)  I'm looking to update it tonight as soon as I read up and get the new version from RIGOL.  It appears I have the current boot loader (1.09)

Can you please elaborate on what tweaks you did? And how you are load testing/burning it it?  I may post this question as a separate thread.  Your braver than I, I'm dying to open it up, but don't want to void my warranty.  :scared:

Cheers,

Raymond
 

Offline kjdotts

  • Contributor
  • Posts: 35
  • Country: us
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #28 on: April 22, 2015, 04:52:49 pm »
I noticed I only received 2 spare fuses, the documents stated 3.  Are they counting the one in the unit?

I also noticed we don't have the latest firmware.  (00.01.13)  I'm looking to update it tonight as soon as I read up and get the new version from RIGOL.  It appears I have the current boot loader (1.09)

Can you please elaborate on what tweaks you did? And how you are load testing/burning it it?  I may post this question as a separate thread.  Your braver than I, I'm dying to open it up, but don't want to void my warranty.  :scared:

Cheers,

Raymond

I'm heading out the door right now but later tonight I will thoroughly respond. If Rigol doesn't get you the firmware quickly, let me know and I will gladly email you the file.

-Kris
 

Offline kjdotts

  • Contributor
  • Posts: 35
  • Country: us
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #29 on: April 24, 2015, 12:06:24 am »
I noticed I only received 2 spare fuses, the documents stated 3.  Are they counting the one in the unit?
I also only received 2 spare fuses. I did notice that Dave received three spare fuses with his unit (https://youtu.be/IaWgF1SORkk?t=33m46s) so maybe 230v factory configured units receive three vs two for 115v configured units for some reason. Maybe Rigol reduced the number to two at some point in the past.

Can you please elaborate on what tweaks you did? And how you are load testing/burning it it?  I may post this question as a separate thread.  Your braver than I, I'm dying to open it up, but don't want to void my warranty. :scared:
Admittedly, I'm very OCD, especially when it comes to anything I spend my hard earned money on. I tend to only buy high quality and therefore I have high expectations. While thoroughly testing and evaluating my unit, I noted a few minor quality control related issues which didn't justify a return but did bug me enough to tweak them. The main issue was the green chassis ground binding post. I noticed it was loose (clockwise/counterclockwise movement when tightening/loosening the binding post knob). The other issue was the LCD display, rubber membrane buttons and rotary encoder knob were off center to the far left. No huge issue, just aesthetically displeasing. These issues were evident prior to teardown, I discovered a few others during teardown (see below).

Once I had thoroughly tested, evaluated and burned my unit in (I'll explain what I mean by “burn in” below), I removed (using wax paper) the factory warranty seal and stored it on a folded piece of wax paper. I then attached the wax paper to a printout of the picture I took of the factory installed seal before removal (for future reinstallation reference, see below images). I waited to open my unit up until I was completely happy with my tests/evaluation and intended to keep the unit (no need to open the unit up for minor tweaking if some major “return justified” issue developed first).

Teardown Issues & Resolutions:

Once I had the factory warranty seal safely removed and stored, I proceeded to teardown my unit. Looking back on the experience, I'm glad I did because numerous issues were brought to light and resolved...
  • ISSUE: While utilizing the carry handle, I noticed a rough feel/operation when the handle was pulled/released. I also noticed some paint shavings when removing the handle.
    RESOLUTION: During reassembly, I installed the metal core of the handle on the opposite side from how it was installed at the factory. The metal core of the handle appears to be stamped out, resulting in a side with smooth edges and a side with sharp edges. The sharp edged side was installed facing the paint finish at the factory. This resulted in the paint finish rapidly getting worn down to bare metal and rough operation. By simply flipping the metal core over, no more finish damage and silky smooth operation.
  • ISSUE: Three stripped out chassis Torx screw heads (one securing top board assembly to the chassis and two securing front panel assembly to the chassis).
    RESOLUTION: Cleaned up Torx screw heads with a file and carefully/properly torqued down during reassembly.
  • ISSUE: Sloppily bundled wire bundles which were poorly routed resulting in several wires being situated up against and rubbing a raw/sharp edge of the chassis (potential for issues over time).
    RESOLUTION: Disconnected all interconnects during disassembly. During reassembly, cleanly routed and wire tied all wires/bundles.
  • ISSUE: Green chassis ground binding post loose.
    RESOLUTION: Visually verified issue. Lock washer was just slightly contacted by binding post nut. All the other binding post lock washers were nearly completely flattened by their respective nut. I tightened the nut until properly torqued (visually matching the other lock washers). I also took this opportunity to correctly align the binding post through hole which was previously off center. Now, all seven binding post through holes are perfectly centered.
  • ISSUE: LCD display, rubber membrane buttons and rotary encoder knob were off center to the far left.
    RESOLUTION: The front panel is engineered in such a way that there is horizontal/vertical play in the LCD/PCB/rubber membrane button assembly when all the screws are loosened. There is just enough play to create a sloppy appearance if you adjust the assembly to the extreme left/right/top/bottom or even rotate it and create a tilted LCD display issue. There are guide holes integrated in to the assembly to aid in proper centering which the Rigol employee ignored during assembly. I simply loosened all the screws and centered everything up properly. Again, it's just an aesthetic issue but I spent my hard earned money on this unit so I want it as near perfect as possible.
I know, I knooow, I knoooooow... OCD to the extreme. I realize this. However, realize that I'm setting up my home electronics lab (in my recently acquired 12' x 24' finished basement) and beginning the process of passing on my knowledge of electronics to my twelve year old son. So, I want everything as near perfect as possible. He's sat in and observed/participated/learned a ton during this process. The purchases I'm making now, I plan to pass on to him in the future. For Christmas, I hooked him up with a beginner electronics kit and a bunch of Arduino gear. He's probably one of the few twelve year old kids on the planet with Fluke 87V and Rigol DP832 experience.

”Burn In” Explanation:

When I say “burn in”, I simply mean extensive operation, testing and evaluation of the unit over the course of several days (starting the day I received the unit from UPS). The Rigol authorized dealer I purchased the unit from has a certain return window, so, the purpose is to expose any issues which might warrant a return as close to initial receipt of the unit as possible. In other words, before I'm stuck with a potentially defective unit, I want to know of any issues and either resolve them or return for exchange/refund.

During the “burn in” period, I...
  • Inspected the unit for quality control related issues (and discovered a few).
  • Functionally checked every aspect of the unit. During my functional checks, I discovered two bugs (which I reported here at the EEVblog and I plan to report to Rigol).
  • Verified calibration throughout the voltage/current ranges numerous times (always well within spec).
  • Loaded the unit up to 100% of rated spec for a few minutes and then dropped down to 70-80% of  rated spec and ran for an hour or so.
  • Ran the unit continuously for a 24-hour period. During this time (which fell on a weekend), I became intimately familiar with every aspect of my Rigol DP832. I had a blast. Yes, I stayed awake all 24 hours enjoying my purchase!
  • Monitored the unit for any thermal issues.
With the questionable history of the Rigol DP832 (engineering failures, thermal issues, PCB revisions, etc...), I wanted to ensure my unit was as near perfect as possible. My unit is equipped with what I believe are the newest revisions of the TopBoard (v02.20) and BottomBoard (v02.20). Therefore, I especially wanted to make sure everything was good to go analog board wise.

Warranty Seal Removal/Storage:

As stated above, I removed (using wax paper) the factory warranty seal and stored it on a folded piece of wax paper. I then attached the wax paper to a printout of the picture I took of the factory installed seal before removal (for future reinstallation reference). This, along with the certificate of calibration, documentation, purchase receipt, serial number documentation, etc... are all filed away for safe keeping.

NOTE: Consider carefully the risk to your factory warranty if you decide to try and replicate what I have posted below. Patience, a steady hand and practiced technique are required to successfully execute this. One wrong move and your warranty will be voided! I've been doing this for many years so I have the process perfected. Even if I hadn't decided to teardown my unit, I would have removed and stored the factory warranty seal just to protect it. These seals are very fragile and you can easily damage them (voiding your warranty) just from normal use/handling, even if you don't actually open your unit up. Just look at Dave's seal, it was damaged prior to him tearing his unit down after only owning it for a short period of time (https://youtu.be/s4rV20ulsm0?t=1m16s).

Moderators: I've reviewed the forum rules and don't believe I'm violating any rule(s) by posting this technique here. I apologize in advance if you take issue with this.


-Kris
 

Offline broderpTopic starter

  • Regular Contributor
  • *
  • Posts: 64
  • Country: us
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #30 on: April 24, 2015, 12:54:36 am »
 :wtf: wow.  Thanks for the very precise explanation Kris.   :)

Rest assured you are not alone with your OCD.  ;D Although I will admit yours is worse than mine.  My OCD for example makes me open DVD and Blu-Ray movies with a razor blade so I can remove the shrink wrapping as a sleeve and reuse it to keep dust off the case.  Music CD's as well.   :palm:

But darn you sir for bringing all this to my attention... ;)  I didn't notice any of these issues until I read your post! lol

My unit also has just about every control shifted to the left a bit.  I had to look close but it's there.  The worst one is the 'wanky' display mode button to bring up those "dials" that Dave hated in his video, followed by the channel select buttons.  The rest are maybe a 1/32" or less off, but noticeable now that I know what to look for..... |O

I'm also a neat freak when it comes to wiring, using wire ties, routing wires, shrink wrapping wires, or just about anything that involves keeping thing super tidy.  I'm going to not open mine up just yet, but if the issues we have in common keep bugging me, I may have to.  I don't seem to have the same issues (externally anyways) that you do.  My handle is smooth and all my terminals are tight, if not just a small fraction to the left.  :palm:

What did you do to load up the supply?  I don't have anything substantial at the moment to do this.  I was considering some large PC fans or something, but I have no way to hook them up.  Maybe I can get some large load resistors from work if I can find some that will let me burn in or test all channels at 3A then around 2.5A for a few hours. 

Mine was purchased thru TEquipment.net.  I'll contact them about the fuses, just because it bugs me Dave got 3, my document says 3 but I got 2.  ::)

I also managed to upgrade my Firmware last night.  Not easy with the wrong instructions given to me by RIGOL.  So far so good, but it would have literally taken 2 minutes with the correct instructions and not the 45 I wound up taking.

Thanks again Kris for the details.  Good to hear your son it taking an interest.  I also have a 12year old, but to him if it doesn't involve a controller and shooting someone on the big screen TV, he's bored with it.  He is however a very talented musician (violin), so this may be his thing. I was a drummer for many years before the engineering bug hit me.


 

 

Offline kjdotts

  • Contributor
  • Posts: 35
  • Country: us
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #31 on: April 24, 2015, 02:18:34 am »
:wtf: wow.  Thanks for the very precise explanation Kris.   :)

You're welcome.

Rest assured you are not alone with your OCD.  ;D Although I will admit yours is worse than mine.  My OCD for example makes me open DVD and Blu-Ray movies with a razor blade so I can remove the shrink wrapping as a sleeve and reuse it to keep dust off the case.  Music CD's as well.   :palm:

I completely understand. I have a collection of ~1400 DVDs and ~600 Blu-rays. I dropped physical music media years ago but I have ~10,000 albums in my digital music collection.

But darn you sir for bringing all this to my attention... ;)  I didn't notice any of these issues until I read your post! lol

My unit also has just about every control shifted to the left a bit.  I had to look close but it's there.  The worst one is the 'wanky' display mode button to bring up those "dials" that Dave hated in his video, followed by the channel select buttons.  The rest are maybe a 1/32" or less off, but noticeable now that I know what to look for..... |O

I'm also a neat freak when it comes to wiring, using wire ties, routing wires, shrink wrapping wires, or just about anything that involves keeping thing super tidy.  I'm going to not open mine up just yet, but if the issues we have in common keep bugging me, I may have to.  I don't seem to have the same issues (externally anyways) that you do.  My handle is smooth and all my terminals are tight, if not just a small fraction to the left.  :palm:

Sorry! You asked for it so you got it. ;) I'm like the evil friend who comes to visit and points out a dead pixel you hadn't noticed on your fancy new LCD TV. >:D Seriously, I wouldn't worry about the front panel based on your description. Everything on mine was shifted to the extreme left and very noticeable. The binding post issue was the main reason I performed a complete teardown since you must to properly get the front panel removed. After all the tweaks, I am 100% happy with my unit.

Well, better get back to working on my electronics lab. Later!

-Kris
 

Offline Mr. Scram

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 9810
  • Country: 00
  • Display aficionado
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #32 on: September 11, 2017, 08:22:48 pm »
Sorry for kicking an old thread and my ignorance, but I feel the original question has not been answered quite yet. The only reason I see given for spending well over twice the amount of the Korad on the Rigol is that "it's nicer". You'll have to forgive me for feeling that answer is lacking a bit of substance. The Rigol seems to have better accuracy after being upgraded for yet more money. Are there any other differences that really warrant spending the money for the Rigol?

I don't really consider the Korad a hit and miss affair, considering it's been sold by Dave for quite a while and many people on the forums seem to own or use it. I just hope to understand the differences properly, as to make an informed decision myself.
 

Offline thm_w

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 6378
  • Country: ca
  • Non-expert
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #33 on: September 11, 2017, 11:29:20 pm »
Sorry for kicking an old thread and my ignorance, but I feel the original question has not been answered quite yet. The only reason I see given for spending well over twice the amount of the Korad on the Rigol is that "it's nicer". You'll have to forgive me for feeling that answer is lacking a bit of substance. The Rigol seems to have better accuracy after being upgraded for yet more money. Are there any other differences that really warrant spending the money for the Rigol?

I don't really consider the Korad a hit and miss affair, considering it's been sold by Dave for quite a while and many people on the forums seem to own or use it. I just hope to understand the differences properly, as to make an informed decision myself.

Korad has no ethernet or digital I/O.
You said yourself, better accuracy. The upgrade can be had for free if you desire.
UI is vastly different, watch a video of both in operation and see if the difference is worth it to you. Is it worth being able to see power consumption, and all three channels at the same time? Is it worth being able to type in the voltage/current? That's up to you.
Profile -> Modify profile -> Look and Layout ->  Don't show users' signatures
 

Offline IAmBack

  • Regular Contributor
  • *
  • Posts: 163
  • Country: pl
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #34 on: September 12, 2017, 07:18:06 am »
And how about OVP/OCP in Rigol vs Corad? Consiedring that Rigol's protection reacts after 400-800ms it is safe to say, that this PSU has no OCP/OVP feature. I'm wondering, how it is with Corad's protection. Can anyone test Korad at this matter?
 

Offline Mr. Scram

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 9810
  • Country: 00
  • Display aficionado
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #35 on: September 12, 2017, 11:08:00 pm »
Korad has no ethernet or digital I/O.
You said yourself, better accuracy. The upgrade can be had for free if you desire.
UI is vastly different, watch a video of both in operation and see if the difference is worth it to you. Is it worth being able to see power consumption, and all three channels at the same time? Is it worth being able to type in the voltage/current? That's up to you.
The Korad can be read and controlled through a PC. It also seems to be a little more convenient to control without navigating menu's. On the other hand, Dave's remark about the Rigol having a built in multimeter is spot-on. That justifies at least part of the extra cost. Obviously, you can do the same by adding actual multimeters, but that isn't quite as convenient.

I think I'm leaning towards the Korad at the moment, not in small part because it's not too silly to add the Rigol later. Having two power supplies isn't really extravagant and if that ever happens, the cheaper Korad can serve as a beater unit to do less responsible things with.
 

Offline mklimasz

  • Newbie
  • Posts: 3
  • Country: pl
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #36 on: September 19, 2017, 10:11:09 am »
Regarding OVP/OCP in Korad - I can report, that the reaction is (almost) immediate; however, I haven't measured it properly (in terms of over/under-shooting nor timing - it is just what I've observed when stress testing the PSU). If it is critical, I might do so - using resistive load.
 

Offline bson

  • Supporter
  • ****
  • Posts: 2270
  • Country: us
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #37 on: September 19, 2017, 11:36:19 pm »
And how about OVP/OCP in Rigol vs Corad? Consiedring that Rigol's protection reacts after 400-800ms it is safe to say, that this PSU has no OCP/OVP feature. I'm wondering, how it is with Corad's protection. Can anyone test Korad at this matter?
The Rigol's CC response is much faster than that, and CC is your main circuit protection mechanism with a lab supply.   The OVP protects the supply from your circuit, and how fast it needs to be depends on the supply.  Set it to 10V and hook up a 12V lead-acid battery on the output and I'm sure the Rigol will survive until the OVP trips.  It's a GOOD thing that a supply doesn't trip all that fast, or any inductive spike from your circuit would make it a huge nuisance fast.
 

Offline Mr. Scram

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 9810
  • Country: 00
  • Display aficionado
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #38 on: September 19, 2017, 11:57:44 pm »
Regarding OVP/OCP in Korad - I can report, that the reaction is (almost) immediate; however, I haven't measured it properly (in terms of over/under-shooting nor timing - it is just what I've observed when stress testing the PSU). If it is critical, I might do so - using resistive load.
What kind of stress testing did you do? I'm curious to see whether it can take a bit of a beating.
 

Offline IAmBack

  • Regular Contributor
  • *
  • Posts: 163
  • Country: pl
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #39 on: September 20, 2017, 11:43:25 pm »
And how about OVP/OCP in Rigol vs Corad? Consiedring that Rigol's protection reacts after 400-800ms it is safe to say, that this PSU has no OCP/OVP feature. I'm wondering, how it is with Corad's protection. Can anyone test Korad at this matter?
The Rigol's CC response is much faster than that, and CC is your main circuit protection mechanism with a lab supply.   The OVP protects the supply from your circuit, and how fast it needs to be depends on the supply.  Set it to 10V and hook up a 12V lead-acid battery on the output and I'm sure the Rigol will survive until the OVP trips.  It's a GOOD thing that a supply doesn't trip all that fast, or any inductive spike from your circuit would make it a huge nuisance fast.
Spike with 0.5s duration? Isn't 10ms long enough? It's not a inrush current of 1000W squirrel - cage motor or something like this.
It may be, that the best solution is adjustable trip time. Also it could be fine to have the reaction time correlated with over-current: small oc - long time, big oc - short time.
But anyway, it should switch off faster - faster than I can remove screwdriver that is a reason of over-current...
 

Offline dgarciacampos

  • Newbie
  • Posts: 4
  • Country: ca
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #40 on: November 30, 2017, 03:09:24 am »
I would also like to know how one gets the discount from TEquipment?
 

Offline nanofrog

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 5446
  • Country: us
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #41 on: November 30, 2017, 03:16:03 am »
I would also like to know how one gets the discount from TEquipment?
There's a search feature in the upper left.
 

Offline Mr. Scram

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 9810
  • Country: 00
  • Display aficionado
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #42 on: November 30, 2017, 04:24:58 am »
I would also like to know how one gets the discount from TEquipment?
It might very well be they require you to be active and contributing to the forums. In that case, two posts is probably a bit meagre.
 

Offline nanofrog

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 5446
  • Country: us
Re: RIGOL DP832 vs other cheaper supplies.
« Reply #43 on: November 30, 2017, 01:40:03 pm »
I would also like to know how one gets the discount from TEquipment?
It might very well be they require you to be active and contributing to the forums. In that case, two posts is probably a bit meagre.
Precisely the case.  ;) Thus far, it's simultaneously kept the code off of coupon sites and increased participation.

FWIW, it's not based on post counts, but by the amount of content of posts (code requests and LOL & similar comments are exempt from consideration). Some members have qualified with a single post.
 


Share me

Digg  Facebook  SlashDot  Delicious  Technorati  Twitter  Google  Yahoo
Smf