MELF's are terrible, they roll off the board during reflow. And they roll off your bench. And they roll on the floor. Crunch.
When I browse the parts on Mouser, some of the manufacturers have a drawing of MELF diodes that are square bodied and round only on the end. But whenever I buy them, they are all the same cylindrical thing. Is this rectangular MELF a real thing, or too good to be true?
I tend to stick with MELF for zeners, anyhow, because it happens to be one of my known commodities. Some SMD diodes I have bought (without looking hard nuff), only to find they have stupid reflow pads that don't wrap around the sides, at all. And many of the ubiquitous SMD black epoxy packages have a stripe that is very hard to see. So for low current diodes, I like MELF for zeners. They are very easy to identify and to solder. The flux keeps them from rolling around, once I place them on the board.
Never having to flip them over, this more than negates the rolling, IMO.