If you're going to run a second cable, I'd run another Cat6 - and wire up both for ethernet use. This allows you to use either cable for digital (ethernet) traffic or analogue (phone) signals.
You can then use one as a phone line by simply having the appropriate patch cable. You can buy phone cables with RJ45 on one end and RJ12 on the other.
Then, if you want to move to VOIP, you can change the usage of the second line without any rewiring or changing your existing ethernet setup on the other line. Also, with two ethernet lines, you have redundancy and/or expansion - which is never a bad thing.