Can't make out what the probes are connecting to. Why is it significant they are within 5mm? Schematic?
If you are measuring Vo - Vin, and Vo = 200 * Vin, are you not simply measuring 199*Vin, which looks enough like 200 not to notice the difference???
Of course, that wouldn't explain your apparently having 0.5V input. But that begs the question, why are you driving it with 0.5V when the amplifier is utterly incapable of producing 200 * 0.5V = 100V output? Surely it should be clipping to a voltage somewhat below supply?
I don't know enough about that HP scope to tell what traces are what, at what scales, etc. They don't look to be labeled.
Also, are you using 10x probes (or not), and is the scope reading them correctly (auto-detecting, or manually configured)?
Tim