If you have an esd mat and wrist strap it will not matter if your tools are esd safe or not as long as you are in contact with the metal parts of the tool, there will only be a problem if the tool is insulated, if it says insulated to a 1000 volts or something like that there could be a charge on the tool if you are holding it by the plastic handles only touch the metal and you should be safe, that is unless you are trying to cut a live wire with a 1000 volts on it.
Thanks everybody for the info.
Yes, I plan to have a grounded mat and strap (should arrive tomorrow) but I don't think I can touch the cutter's metal each time I use it, I am sure I will forget. Humidity around here is ~50-70%, I guess, so not too bad.
Since I am not invested in an old cutter and need to make a purchase decision I think will go ahead and start looking for an ESD one. Anybody can recommend a good ESD cutter? My preference is for a good quality one.
I am also looking for a small plier, so having it ESD safe will also be nice.
Thanks,
Z.