Probably moisture in the part. It gets hot, develops into vapor and the part "pops" out of place. That's why you get the warnings about moisture, reels are shipped with desiccant bags and moisture indicators. And you are supposed to bake every reel that has been opened for longer than some time before use to get moisture out.
BTW, none of the parts on that board are properly soldered. That paste doesn't look like it has reflowed at all.
Your temperature is too low. You can't follow the reflow profile intended for a reflow oven with a hotplate! Oven heats from both top and bottom and is enclosed, so the thermal losses are much smaller than with a hotplate. Your hotplate heats only from the bottom, through the FR4 which is not a great thermal conductor. So you need higher temperature.
You probably could try to reflow multiple times for a DIY board but you would need to clean off the old paste because the part wouldn't lie flat for new reflow otherwise. However, to fix a capacitor like this it is rather pointless - just rework it using an iron. Much faster and simpler.