Electronics > Beginners
Strange behavior - simulated op-amp rectifier
FriedMule:
--- Quote from: rstofer on January 01, 2020, 11:31:08 pm ---No, the op amps need a power supply as shown in both of your original schematics.
A precision rectifier is used for signal processing, not as some part of a low loss power supply.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precision_rectifier
And pay attention to input and output voltage swings. Some op anps can't work within a couple of volts of the power supply rails. Given +-9V supplies, some opamps will only operate to +-7V on the inputs and outputs. Rail-To-Rail opamps work a lot closer but don't assume rail-to-rail is anything more than a marketing term.
--- End quote ---
I believe you, my thought on using this method is that I have seen many examples where other have used it as a power rectifier and read articles where people have praised this method. But on nearly all of the schematics have there not been shown any supply pins, so maybe it's why it do work in some simulators?
Is there any way to avoid having to use supply? I have thought about using compactors instead and I have thought of an, properly stupid idea, letting some of the finished DC power, back to the Op-Amps supply?
FriedMule:
--- Quote from: fcb on January 01, 2020, 11:51:27 pm ---
--- Quote from: FriedMule on January 01, 2020, 07:57:58 pm ---
--- Quote from: not1xor1 on January 01, 2020, 05:40:44 pm ---
--- Quote from: FriedMule on January 01, 2020, 03:05:44 pm ---Hi
I have, as I mostly do, searched and found some article and a schematic that should be great.
According to the article, this rectifier should be a wary precise full wave version with nearly no loss.
But when I simulate it, it do only rectify the positive AC and on top of that, do it deliver a -2.3V to 9.75V voltage.
Info: input 10V 50Hz
--- End quote ---
The circuit works works as expected in LTspice. (see attachment)
What kind of program are you using?
Did you set a proper supply voltage for the opamps (both positive and negative and greater than the AC input peak voltage)?
--- End quote ---
I am using Micro-cap to do the simulation
I was just about to write that the circuit works fine: http://tinyurl.com/ustlnbx
But many thanks for doing so much out of it, and yes it looks to work fine in LTSpice.
I have tried to change the two Op-Amps to the same model as you used, but still with no luck.
I have not applied any supply voltage on the Op-amps, since there were not applied any on the original drawing. I tried to remove the supply Voltage on your LT-Spice document and that do remove all the function of the circuit.
The function should be a rectifier but if it already demands DC power, then do I need a PSU for that and then a PSU for that circuit, and so on:-)
Isn't it posibly to avoid supply Voltage?
--- End quote ---
I guess at this point it might be prudent to ask what you are trying to achieve?
--- End quote ---
My end goal is to build a Optoisolator dimmer, it runs at 1.2V-1.4V at 0.1uA-50uA
I am thinking of using a simple three resistor current divider, where one resistor is a pot.
To save as much power as possible, do I want to eliminate as much voltage drop as possible.
capt bullshot:
This circuit works as a precision signal rectifier, intended to e.g. measure AC voltages by converting them to DC voltages. It doesn't deliver any power, and requires an external supply to operate at all, indeed it uses more power from the external supply than it uses from the AC input. It's quite common to not show the supply pins in such schematics, they're just implied to be there and appropriately connected to an appropriate supply.
So it's not applicable for your purpose, for minimum voltage drop at low power, use schottky diodes as the rectifier.
FriedMule:
--- Quote from: capt bullshot on January 02, 2020, 09:17:46 am ---This circuit works as a precision signal rectifier, intended to e.g. measure AC voltages by converting them to DC voltages. It doesn't deliver any power, and requires an external supply to operate at all, indeed it uses more power from the external supply than it uses from the AC input. It's quite common to not show the supply pins in such schematics, they're just implied to be there and appropriately connected to an appropriate supply.
So it's not applicable for your purpose, for minimum voltage drop at low power, use schottky diodes as the rectifier.
--- End quote ---
Okay thanks, just a small question, I have seen some use Mosfets with diodes or even schottky's, why do that?
capt bullshot:
--- Quote from: FriedMule on January 02, 2020, 10:15:01 am ---
--- Quote from: capt bullshot on January 02, 2020, 09:17:46 am ---This circuit works as a precision signal rectifier, intended to e.g. measure AC voltages by converting them to DC voltages. It doesn't deliver any power, and requires an external supply to operate at all, indeed it uses more power from the external supply than it uses from the AC input. It's quite common to not show the supply pins in such schematics, they're just implied to be there and appropriately connected to an appropriate supply.
So it's not applicable for your purpose, for minimum voltage drop at low power, use schottky diodes as the rectifier.
--- End quote ---
Okay thanks, just a small question, I have seen some use Mosfets with diodes or even schottky's, why do that?
--- End quote ---
This circuit is an "active diode" rectifier (the MOSFETs acting as low voltage drop diodes). It's useful when you need to conserve power in somewhat higher power applications. This means a few amperes of output current, and for this particular circuit input with an voltage range of 5...10V. For lower voltages, the MOSFETs won't turn on, and for higher voltages you'd need a special driver circuit.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version