Electronics > Beginners
Why is the voltage across my load so far off from the 3V zener diode “regulation
(1/1)
renzoms:
I used a 3V .500W Zener diode 1N5225B for it's voltage regulating abilities. Here is a link to a 47s video including schematics, results, and explanations in voice.
The circuit is Vin, a resistor in series with the Vin (330 ohm), and then the 3V Zener diode and a load (resistor) in parallel.
The Vin ranges from 5V to 9.6V. The load ranges from 330 ohm to 3300 ohm to 33000 ohm. The maximum expected voltage "differentiation" (how far the measured results are from the expected results) is .39V.
For the 3300 ohm and 33000 ohm load the expected result is 3V at 9.6V Vin and 2.61V at 5V Vin. The measured results are 3.01 V, 2.58 V, 2.99V, and 2.61V, respectively. Great!
For the 330 ohm load, the results are 2.81 V and 2.16 V.
Why are the measured results so far from the expected results for the 330 ohm load?
https://youtu.be/f6LKJ-PjRwk
T3sl4co1l:
Low voltage zener diodes (under 5V) have a very soft characteristic. You need to run it at a lot of bias current to stay close to the rating (note it's measured at 20mA).
Tim
Gyro:
You might find that you get better regulation with a series chain of 4 forward biased silicon diodes instead.
Alternatively, you could go the whole hog and use a 3V low-dropout linear regulator. It would be more power efficient than a zener shunt too.
w2aew:
As @blueskull and others have mentioned, low voltage zener diodes have a fairly soft knee in the IV characteristic due to the zener effect. Higher voltage zeners are actually much sharper due to the avalanche effect. I did a video on zeners that you might be interested in. In particular, check out the curve tracer results starting at about 11:45 in the video:
SeanB:
A cheap reasonably good 3V zener is a blue or white LED, though it has a rather soft knee it is a lot sharper than most zener diodes at low current, and also makes a handy power on indicator, though you are best keeping it shadowed from light, as it also can be a photoelectric generator as well.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
Go to full version