General > General Technical Chat
Can Customs X-ray or electromagnetic arcs damage circuits?
luiHS:
I am making shipments to my clients, of various circuits that I manufacture, and I find cases in which the product is installed and it does not work for them. I test everything before shipping.
Specifically, a board with a Kinetis MK66 microcontroller, the customer returns it to me, I test it and it doesn't even allow programming, it's locked.
Two other cases, with Raspberry units that the video output does not work. It is not that it has failed them after a while of use, it is that as soon as it arrives, they install it and it does not work, when I here check everything before sending it.
And since there are already several cases, and not all of the same board, one with my board that has a Kinetis MK66, and another two with Raspberry video failures, I don't know what to think about. The only thing I can think of is that the X-ray or electromagnetic arcs from Customs can damage the circuits, and if I could avoid it by putting the boards inside antistatic bags.
TimFox:
If Customs officials handle your un-shielded circuit boards, they could damage the components with ESD, due to static charges on their hands.
If your components are ESD-sensitive, as most semiconductor devices are, the boards should be shipped in anti-static containers or bags.
X-ray damage to semiconductors is possible, but not likely. Photographic film will be exposed by the relatively-high x-ray dose applied to checked baggage in commercial airliners, but there is little damage with the lower dose applied to carry-on baggage.
(Many of my suppliers use anti-static plastic for all shipments, to avoid stocking multiple shipping materials. When I received some 1/4-20 UNC stainless-steel bolts wrapped in pink plastic, I shuddered to think of the ESD required to damage such objects.)
esepecesito:
I have 1000 times shipped (or received by post), carried on, carry on baggage, and dispatched photo film, and electronics, and have never had an issue. Inspection of electronics with relatively strong X-ray is part of the manufacturing process where I work, so I do not think it would be an issue.
But cannot warranty it is not the problem.
I'd bet ESD miss-handling. But customs deal with ESD all time... I would expect the know what they do... well... anything is possible... :)
TimFox:
Damage by x-ray exposure to normal photographic film in checked baggage is well documented, but I have never encountered a problem with normal film (ISO 100 to 400) in carry-on baggage, although I try to avoid multiple passes through the machines when changing planes. In the US, I have the legal right to hand inspection, but that is not true in Europe and other jurisdictions.
Gyro:
--- Quote from: luiHS on July 09, 2021, 03:46:53 pm ---
I am making shipments to my clients, of various circuits that I manufacture, and I find cases in which the product is installed and it does not work for them. I test everything before shipping.
Specifically, a board with a Kinetis MK66 microcontroller, the customer returns it to me, I test it and it doesn't even allow programming, it's locked.
Two other cases, with Raspberry units that the video output does not work. It is not that it has failed them after a while of use, it is that as soon as it arrives, they install it and it does not work, when I here check everything before sending it.
And since there are already several cases, and not all of the same board, one with my board that has a Kinetis MK66, and another two with Raspberry video failures, I don't know what to think about. The only thing I can think of is that the X-ray or electromagnetic arcs from Customs can damage the circuits, and if I could avoid it by putting the boards inside antistatic bags.
--- End quote ---
I'm not clear whether your products are built into enclosures or are just exposed PCBs.
If they are PCBs, then you should absolutely be using antistatic bags. I would leave negative feedback for even an ebay seller if they sent me a board of any value without ESD protection.
It's not just handling, by customs or even by the customer when opening your packaging, but bubble wrap and other non-conductive packaging can easily generate damaging voltages when being jostled around in transit.
I don't think X-ray has anything to do with your problem. Far too many complex electronic products are shipped through normal commercial channels for this to be an issue.
P.S. It is so easy to seal antistatic bags with simple heat sealers these days, so that the contents cannot be handled without cutting them open. ESD labels are cheap too to warn of the risk.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
Go to full version