My advice: avoid pushing rotary switch. It seems that this mechanism is rather fragile.
I can not imagine how you can push one rotary switch, but this can be only me.

Even so, if you had to push it, because you was thinking, that it would improve the contact of it with the PCB,
this was a wrong idea, all that it needs are some fast motion,
about 3-4 times forth-word and backward movements, and it will be fine.
If you do have oxidized contacts, email Extech about the problem and report back in this thread with their answer.
I would like to know if they will react with professionalism,
and send back to you, one new range switch free of charge.