Sodium lamps are certainly more pleasant to the eye, but LEDs are a bit of a no brainer when it comes to energy costs (150W vs 600W+ adds up for thousands of lamps) another positive is they tend to throw light downwards so there is a reduction in light pollution (at least that is how the council advertised the upgrade to LED). You will need thick curtains however if you have a bedroom window near a lamppost. We had LEDs installed 4/5 years ago, wasn't a fan of the bright white light at first, but used to it now.
I had the opposite experience. My street used to have LPS and was upgraded to LED about a year and a half ago. The lamp that's visible from my bedroom is about one lot along and on the other side of the street. Also, the top of my bedroom window is at nearly the same elevation as the lamp head, due to the house being higher than the street.
The old lamp, with its hemispherical diffuser, used to shine in my bedroom window quite brightly at night, casting a bright projection of the window on the wall, which would then by scattering illuminate the whole room dimly. When I was a little kid, my parents had to install a blackout blind so I could sleep. (When we renovated, it was replaced by a fancy wooden top-down/bottom-up blind, which doesn't block as much light, but I'm no longer as sensitive to light when sleeping.)
The new LED lamp emits much less light sideways, and while you can still see a projection on the wall, it's very dim and it doesn't perceptibly illuminate the room. When it was installed, I was surprised to be in pretty much total darkness the first time I turned off the room lighting at night with the blind open—the old LPS lamp gave enough light to see my way around the room by!
Somewhat off the direct topic, but maybe of general interest.
I grew up in the UK, and back then, (dodging dinosaurs), street lighting was controlled by electro-mechanical time switched. A small synchronous motor drove gearing turning the switch once per 24 hours. settings on the clock face would flip a microswitch on/off at the set times.
The timers for street lights had one extra feature, more gearing for a cam that turned once per year. This cam advanced/retarded the set times to follow daylight at (about) 52 degrees latitude. So long as someone went around and adjusted them after any power outage (rare in those days) they worked fine. Turning on the lights at dusk, and off at daybreak.
Ah the venerable Venner, I begged a few of those from the guys who refitted the lights in my street with photoelectric cells, the Venner switches were an absolute work of mechanical art and must have been in use for decades
Yes, I think that was the make. I had one, just could never think of a good use for it :-)
But you are right, mechanical works of art.
Big Clive did a video on a Sangamo brand streetlamp timer, for anybody who wants to see what one of those timers looks like inside: