General > General Technical Chat
Massive ripoff attempt on next door neighbour thwarted
(1/7) > >>
VK3DRB:
My next door neighbour owns a DeLonghi wine cooler out of warranty - a small fridge. It stopped working and he called a repairman. The repairman charged him $240 to remove a faulty circuit board. Fair enough. It is a very simple PCB with a 7812 type 12V linear regulator on it and a relay and not much else. Look at the photo here.

The technician told my neighbour a replacement board costs... wait for it...$1,200 plus labour to install it. About $1,700 all up including the $240 to come out in the first place... more than what the Italian branded whitegoods rubbish is worth.

My neighbour thought it was a bit expensive and he told the repairman he'll think about it, then he dropped by my house with the board. The electrolytic cap was a bit bulging (tested OK though) and the 7812 had a dead short internally. I had a spare LM340T-12 voltage regulator and a high quality electrolytic capacitor to replace the hu-flung-dung brand capacitor. Cost was nothing to me and I won't charge my neighbour anything as he is a nice bloke and a good neighbour.

Part of Australian culture is that ripping people off is seriously frowned upon. Was this a red herring, or is this sort of ripoff more commonplace?

johansen:
i'm in western washington and i've seen posts on reddit that suggest i could make money.. driving all the way to california, and back.. to change out a compressor on wine fridges.

to some extent the prices they get estimates for.. are just the cost of having a repair man within half an hour of housing prices at 20 million an acre.
Dan123456:
I think it’s pretty common unfortunately  :( A lot of industries don’t repair anything anymore as the labour cost is too high compared to what they would make from the repair  :(

For instance, back in my mechanic days everything was just remove and replace so you might have one broken wire in a car that could be soldered back together… but the boss man will charge the customer for a whole new harness plus a days worth of labor to fit it.

I can’t speak from first hand experience on whitegoods, but have heard similar stories from mates saying repairing their dishwasher or what not was gonna be 2 or 3 times more expensive than a new one!
Halcyon:

--- Quote from: VK3DRB on November 27, 2023, 06:48:29 am ---Part of Australian culture is that ripping people off is seriously frowned upon. Was this a red herring, or is this sort of ripoff more commonplace?

--- End quote ---

I have no doubt that dodgy operators are out there. However this is insanity.

For those reading along at home, if the unit was slightly out of warranty, you could make a claim citing Australian Consumer Law. I'm sure DeLonghi being a "reputable" brand would have just sent out their service techs, or at the very least, a replacement part for free.

But you get what you pay for. I recently had to get someone to look at my Bosch/Siemens dishwasher which was leaking and triggering a "water doesn't belong here" error. The unit was purchased in 2015 and has been great to this day.

I went to the Bosch website, logged a service job and they sent a local company out the following day. The part (something to do with the sump) was replaced at no charge. Bosch identified that there was a design defect in that model during manufacture which caused a seal to leak over time. The faulty part was replaced and I wasn't out of pocket. I was actually shocked, as I fully expected to pay at least a call-out fee, but nope, Bosch took it upon themselves to remedy the issue for free without me even asking. THAT'S service and it's the reason why I wouldn't hesistate to buy a Bosch appliance again. It's been rock solid.

Meanwhile my neighbour bought a cheap dishwasher from Aldi (some rebadged Chinese rubbish). He has been through 2 units in 3 months and the second unit is now faulty with the same problem.
BradC:

--- Quote from: VK3DRB on November 27, 2023, 06:48:29 am ---Part of Australian culture is that ripping people off is seriously frowned upon. Was this a red herring, or is this sort of ripoff more commonplace?
--- End quote ---

It seems to be par for the course when involving wine fridges. "Cost down" design at top of the market prices. Take a cheap fridge, change the thermostat and put a glass door on and sell it for 6 times the price.

Then again maybe I've repaired enough that I'm just old and bitter.
Navigation
Message Index
Next page
There was an error while thanking
Thanking...

Go to full version
Powered by SMFPacks Advanced Attachments Uploader Mod