Cons:
I need a proper power jack, with 5...12V input capability - a cheap buck converter onboard will suffice.
Let's face it, Micro USB is one of the worst connectors out there.
I mostly agree, though an on-board buck would push the cost up and probably increase early mortality due to numpties using unsuitable PSUs.
You aren't *supposed* to put more than 2A through a Micro-B or AB USB connector (see USB.org power delivery standards). The Raspberry Pi Foundation already recommends a 2.5A PSU for a Pi 3B or 3B+. The 3B+ on-board power consumption has been measured at 610mA with a high CPU load - see
https://www.raspberrypi.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=63&t=208110That doesn't include power to optional off-board peripherals - up to 500mA each to four USB devices, plus whatever active HDMI accessories, Camera module etc. take, so its already likely to be overloaded by 'power'
users.
Future Pi's are crying out for a power connector that can handle 15W reliably - whether that's 3A @5V, or a more reasonable 1.9A at 9V to 0.9A at 18V feeding an on-board buck converter. Possibly add a 4 pin PC style fan connector fed from the buck input voltage, with PWM control and tacho feedback without using up GPIO port pins, as thermal management is becoming increasingly problematic as the SoC clock speed goes up and richer on-board peripherals are added.
The POE hat connector is a step in the right direction (and is probably the best way to feed a 3B+ if you are integrating it into anything serious) as at least its an 0.1" pitch square pin header, which if you use good quality gold plated female contacts, should be good for up to 3A DC onto the board, however they cheap-skated it by not using a six pin header with two grounds and two +5V pins in parallel to derate it enough for long-term reliability.