General > General Technical Chat
Statistics, what are the odds...
(1/1)
joeqsmith:
The population of the USA is around 328.2 million people.
There are four states that begin with the letter 'I'.
Illinois, population 12.67 million
Indiana, pop 6.73 million
Idaho, pop 1.787 million
Iowa, pop 3.155 million
For a total of 24.34 million.
In 2018, the number of motorcycles in use were 12.231 million. Or around 3.7% or the population. Assuming that spread is roughly the same for all states, of the four states beginning with 'I', we have roughly 900K riders.
Males make up 81% of the riders in the USA. This mean in these 4 states, we have somewhere around 172.34K female riders.
Females with the name of Carol seems to be somewhere in the order of 0.8%. So in these four states, we have roughly 1378 female riders named Carol.
To narrow it down further, what are the chanced that two of these females were the same age and both took a motorcycle class within 8 days of one another. Not just any motorcycle class but one specifically for three wheel motorcycles. Then, both of them have a single vehicle accident and both die as a result.
While the news carried both stories in the two different states, no one seemed to find it interesting that these two stories were so closely related.
September 28, 2020 Sunday
Carol McMurray, age 66
Indianapolis woman participating in a training course Sunday at Columbus Municipal Airport
lost control of a 2020 Can-Am Ryker (three wheeler) and struck a metal storage container.
Local paper for Columbus
http://www.therepublic.com/2020/09/28/motorcyclist-dies-in-accident-on-training-course-at-airport/
https://www.wthr.com/article/news/local/indianapolis-woman-killed-in-crash-during-motorcycle-training-course/531-d26d76ad-781c-4cd0-b62f-a6c317f05595
Obituary
https://insideeko.com/carol-mcmurray-killed-death-dead-carol-mcmurray-obituary/
Oct 03, 2020 Saturday
Carol Counelis, age 66
DuPage County woman participating in a motorcycle safety training course at Harper College in Palatine
student killed in the crash hit a curb and was ejected from the motorcycle.
the crash occurred was the three-wheel basic rider course
https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/breaking/ct-woman-dies-harper-college-motorcycle-course-20201005-5w2t62viwnbqxabblmv5msq2h4-story.html
Obituary
https://www.legacy.com/obituaries/chicagotribune/obituary.aspx?n=carol-n-counelis&pid=196917432
T3sl4co1l:
Don't forget to add confirmation biases: this probably doesn't happen every year. A one-off doesn't mean anything -- how often has this happened in the past?
How many other combinations does it work with (e.g., different sets of states with some trivial relationship between them)?
A popular, related quirk (I wouldn't call it a phenomenon) is husband and wife discovering childhood pictures they were in. A one-in-a-million occurrence to be sure, but that's still a few hundred cases in the US alone. :)
Tim
CatalinaWOW:
I think you will find this occurrence somewhat unique because many states don't have a mandatory 3wheeler motor cycle course. And if you looked up the numbers you might be stunned at how many of those female riders have taken the course over the last few years.
Probably the most amazing statistic is two fatalities in a safety training course in an interval of a year or less. If an audit of the course (requirements, equipment, syllabus and so on) isn't already underway someone should be shot. Small sample size may be poisoning the information but it would appear that taking the safety training is at least as dangerous as normal operation.
David Hess:
Reduces to a birthday problem.
newbrain:
The odds are what they are...lowish but non-null.
It's only that that one doesn't notice all the times it doesn't happen.
Recent, vaguely relevant XKCD
Navigation
[0] Message Index
Go to full version