Sorry for reviving an old thread. I've been following this campaign regularly, not because I am interested in the product - I think it is an incredibly useless, impractical and inefficient solution in search of a problem - but because this is a prime example of the bad approach that so-called entrepreneurs and startups are taking to product design nowadays.
Firstly, to my knowledge, there is no proper video showing the device working, the only videos they released are like 10s long. If they are this far and this late in the development why not release a simple video showing the device in everyday use?
Secondly, well over a year ago they announced that they were only a couple of weeks away from shipping. Then they said something which sounded like "oh we just need to send the prototype for FCC testing, we'll postpone shipment by a couple of weeks just in case, no worries". Any electrical engineer who has worked on a real product development should know well enough that even the simplest design can be a big headache to pass through FCC/EMC testing! To assume that a product that is not only an intentional radiator but that needs to radiate the claimed 10W (actually 10W is the supposed received power so transmit power is, I guess, more) of power would pass certifications in a couple of weeks is totally insane!! This says a lot about the 4 'expert' masters degree holding engineers listed in the campaign, although to be fair, they might have warned the CEO, whom, with his 'self-taught' engineering skills decided it must not be that hard. This is the so-called 'think outside the box' attitude of many 'entrepreneurs': "experts must be wrong because they are locked into what they were thought, but I as a self-thaught guy am free to explore innovative ideas". Even to just book a timeslot at a test lab often takes several weeks, and rarely a product passes on first attempt (unless it is a really basic or familiar design), it should be obvious to anyone with basic engineering knowledge that a product like this is bound to have a hard time passing the testing.
The saga continues as they say that "hey we passed part 15, so no worries we just need to finish part 18 and some paper-work". Part 15 is just the stuff that any product needs to pass, it has mostly nothing to do with the wireless power transmission which is the main FCC challenge in this product. With a good power supply, good PCB design some, filtering and maybe shielding part 15 is not a big deal. Part 18 is the deal-breaker in this product!!
I don't think this is a scam as such but a prime example of zero experience in designing a product for manufacturing. It is sad that campaigns like this put bad light onto crowd-funding platforms.
Home
Help
Search
Login
Register
