a thick coating of paint thats sanded (where possible) afterwards, I am not too concerned about non uniformity that is much less thicker then the paint layer, but how well that paint stays on.
Alodine makes a change, the self etching primer does not really do anything (wash it off a while later after you paint it). Compared to the etching you get from like alumiprep its a joke IMO.
However, I don't want to deal with alodine. That is a huge hassle. This electro etching thing is not a hassle.
I just wanna know how electro marking works as paint prep.
I never actually saw much of it. it just seems promising, given the mill-scale paint fan club. The post phosphoric acid not polished but tarnished aluminum reminds me of mill scale on mild steel to a small degree. It feels rough. I assume the magnesium nitrate one would be even better.
and the alloy can be anything. if the same stuff works on both stainless steel and aluminum in the data sheet, I assume it will work for most common kinds of aluminum. The electrobrush process is absolutely kick ass. I want more from it. I am waiting for that can of aluminum primer paint to go flat and piss me off at some random time from now.
I also think you can probobly make some super electrolytic degreaser step, that might not be cosmetic, but I imagine that TSP mixture I saw some where on the forum a while back might really degrease the shit out of parts. I am hoping to spritz it off with distilled water in a spray bottle after all the other steps and have it ready for painting without the ultrasonics and alcohols and other crap
the optimal result would be electrocleaning (and maybe degreasing if thats not good enough with some alkali), marking, rinsing and painting. maybe with just a top coat if its good enough without the primer all together. wishful thinking maybe but its worth investigating