That does seem strange. You could test one ?
To be honest, I think I somehow damaged the chip as a result of my careless actions...
I ordered a pair of new ones, but they will arrive in a few weeks.
Another thing that confused me about the datasheet was:
The voltage across the external sense resistor (R1) is fed to the FB pin for sensing. When the voltage exceeds VSET voltage the OUT goes lower, decreasing the drive to the external transistor.