TL07x series are quite popular for audio, as are the NE5532 series.
would prefer to use something with a single +5V supply to match the rest of my circuit.
These requirements aren't quite compatible...
How about RC4580? It goes within about a volt of each rail and is specified down to +/- 2V, so on a single 5V rail you could get an output from 1 to 4V. It's about $1 in single quantity, so not incredibly cheap ($0.50 each amplifier, it's a dual op amp), but has decent characteristics for audio (5-9 nV/rtHz noise, 0.0005% THD, 50mA max output current).
(THD really needs to be specified in dB, I hate counting zeros...)