Electronics > Projects, Designs, and Technical Stuff
Do we still need electrolytic capacitors (for basic decoupling)?
(1/1)
TheUnnamedNewbie:
This might sound like a big of a strange question, but I have spent the last few days diving deep into the concepts of decoupling capacitors, with lots of simulations and modeling.

It got me thinking - Most LDOs have pretty good output impedance up to a few tens of kHz. Past the few tens of kHz, you are already into the regime where big electrolytic caps (especially when combined with trace inductance) are past self-resonance.

So that makes me wonder - are big electrolytics still useful? (I realize some other applications where you have high pulse-loads are a different matter entirely).
Do you still use them? Are you sure there is still a point to using them?
Siwastaja:
Great for damping resonances and peaking whenever you need to use large values of low-ESR ceramic capacitance - such as input circuitry of most switching converters.

Say, you have 100uF of ceramic capacitance - put a 470uF cheap elcap in parallel. Boom, 100% input overshoot reduced to a few %.
David Hess:

--- Quote from: TheUnnamedNewbie on April 02, 2020, 12:54:07 pm ---It got me thinking - Most LDOs have pretty good output impedance up to a few tens of kHz. Past the few tens of kHz, you are already into the regime where big electrolytic caps (especially when combined with trace inductance) are past self-resonance.
--- End quote ---

Just because they are past self resonance doesn't mean they are not providing useful decoupling; their impedance is still low to usefully high frequencies.


--- Quote ---So that makes me wonder - are big electrolytics still useful? (I realize some other applications where you have high pulse-loads are a different matter entirely).
--- End quote ---

They are hard to beat economically when bulk output capacitance is required.  I only see them entirely replaced when long life and high temperature operation is required.
Navigation
Message Index
There was an error while thanking
Thanking...

Go to full version
Powered by SMFPacks Advanced Attachments Uploader Mod