Electronics > Projects, Designs, and Technical Stuff
For an opamp input, which network protection is preferable?
<< < (4/4)
schmitt trigger:
To all of you, thanks for your valuable suggestions.

While I was researching the topic, I found this very interesting e-book from TI. Similar in tone to Analog's fabled "Analogue Dialogue" booklets.  :-+

While the better seasoned engineers will know most of the information, most of us will find very helpful tips to improve our circuits. To me it was chapter 28: The unused op amp: what to do? I always grounded the inputs, but that is probably not the best strategy.

http://www.ti.com/lit/ml/slyt701/slyt701.pdf
David Hess:

--- Quote from: schmitt trigger on April 17, 2019, 06:17:12 pm ---The standard protection network as shown in (A), series schottkys to V+ and V-, works fine. But schottkys have significant leakage, and because of the 1 Meg impedance, it could generate offset voltage errors.
--- End quote ---

Use low capacitance low leakage diodes like 2N3904 base-emitter (or base-collector for higher voltage) junctions and a lower input series resistance.  Bypass the input series resistance with 1000 picofarads to swamp the capacitance of the diodes and amplifier.


--- Quote ---Therefore I was thinking along the lines of inverse parallel diodes from input to ground, as shown in (B). But while the reverse-bias capacitance is well specified, the capacitance below the forward bias is not. Using my Peak Atlas LCR meter, a pair of antiparallel 1N4148 show about 50 pF, which could cause loading at higher frequencies.

I don't know how much I can trust this reading.
--- End quote ---

LCR meters generally have trouble making this measurement without help.

Diode datasheets usually have a capacitance versus voltage graph.

Use two diodes in series to halve the capacitance.

Higher reverse voltages lower the capacitance.


--- Quote ---I had read somewhere that LEDs, covered to avoid photoelectric effects, show both ultra-low leakage and minimum capacitance. Again using the Peak Atlas, 3 mm green LEDs measures 15 pF.
--- End quote ---

I do not know about the capacitance but LEDs often do make good low leakage diodes.
TimFox:
Diode capacitance at or very near zero can be high.  Instead of returning each diode to ground, you can reverse bias it by connecting to another diode that is forward-biased with a small current; when the protection diode is forward-biased, its current adds to the quiescent current of the other diode and the clamp voltage is two diode drops.
I have had good luck with c-b junctions of low-noise audio transistors such as 2N2484 (npn) or 2N4250 (pnp).
Navigation
Message Index
Previous page
There was an error while thanking
Thanking...

Go to full version
Powered by SMFPacks Advanced Attachments Uploader Mod