Author Topic: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications  (Read 4339 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline ricko_ukTopic starter

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 1158
  • Country: gb
Hi,
what type of DC motor (up to 12V) has the lowest inherent electrical noise (both transmission and emission)? I mean by design (i.e. without considering any shielding or filtering I might add later).

Ideally I am looking for a direct drive at a speed from 1 RPM to 200 RPM which I can control via a micro or a pot. If that's too low then I can use a gearbox. Load/torque is very minimal and not a concern and the same for acceleration/deceleration. I just need to rotate a light plastic plate.

Thank you
« Last Edit: May 23, 2020, 06:57:29 pm by ricko_uk »
 

Offline Benta

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 6420
  • Country: de
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #1 on: May 23, 2020, 06:19:11 pm »
If you have AC available, I'd say a shaded pole motor.

 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline nfmax

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 1624
  • Country: gb
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #2 on: May 23, 2020, 06:27:13 pm »
Would a clockwork motor be acceptable? They don't generally have much in the way of electrical noise
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline Benta

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 6420
  • Country: de
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #3 on: May 23, 2020, 06:37:55 pm »
Would a clockwork motor be acceptable? They don't generally have much in the way of electrical noise

Those are normally shaded pole motors :)

 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline nfmax

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 1624
  • Country: gb
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #4 on: May 23, 2020, 06:43:30 pm »
Would a clockwork motor be acceptable? They don't generally have much in the way of electrical noise

Those are normally shaded pole motors :)

I mean a mechanical, spring-driven, wind-up motor. These are 'clockwork' in British English. A shaded-pole, or synchronous, AC motor would be OK, but you still have the possibility of mains-borne interference.
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline Benta

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 6420
  • Country: de
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #5 on: May 23, 2020, 06:49:26 pm »
Would a clockwork motor be acceptable? They don't generally have much in the way of electrical noise

Those are normally shaded pole motors :)

I mean a mechanical, spring-driven, wind-up motor. These are 'clockwork' in British English. A shaded-pole, or synchronous, AC motor would be OK, but you still have the possibility of mains-borne interference.

Ah. This being an electronics forum, that aspect never occurred to me. Then let's include weights and strings, connected vessels etc. as well.  :palm:

AC noise is easily filtered, BTW.

 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline ricko_ukTopic starter

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 1158
  • Country: gb
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #6 on: May 23, 2020, 06:55:56 pm »
Sorry, forgot to specify that the PCB has only DC (can be controlled/varied up to 12V).
« Last Edit: May 23, 2020, 06:59:09 pm by ricko_uk »
 

Offline nfmax

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 1624
  • Country: gb
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #7 on: May 23, 2020, 06:56:53 pm »
Would a clockwork motor be acceptable? They don't generally have much in the way of electrical noise

Those are normally shaded pole motors :)

I mean a mechanical, spring-driven, wind-up motor. These are 'clockwork' in British English. A shaded-pole, or synchronous, AC motor would be OK, but you still have the possibility of mains-borne interference.

Ah. This being an electronics forum, that aspect never occurred to me. Then let's include weights and strings, connected vessels etc. as well.  :palm:

AC noise is easily filtered, BTW.

The application sounds like a turntable for some sort of EMC or antenna measurement system, so the OP may need really low noise. For a bigger turntable load (car, truck, tank...), you could also use a hydraulic motor!  ;)
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Online NiHaoMike

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 9323
  • Country: us
  • "Don't turn it on - Take it apart!"
    • Facebook Page
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #8 on: May 24, 2020, 01:00:26 am »
How about a stepper motor with slew rate controlled drivers?
Cryptocurrency has taught me to love math and at the same time be baffled by it.

Cryptocurrency lesson 0: Altcoins and Bitcoin are not the same thing.
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline ricko_ukTopic starter

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 1158
  • Country: gb
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #9 on: May 24, 2020, 01:19:34 am »
Thank you Mike,
it sounds interesting. I did a search but couldn't find any devices. Can you suggest part numbers or keywords?

Many thanks :)
 

Offline Someone

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 5156
  • Country: au
    • send complaints here
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #10 on: May 24, 2020, 01:34:13 am »
Thank you Mike,
it sounds interesting. I did a search but couldn't find any devices. Can you suggest part numbers or keywords?

Many thanks :)
Stepper motors are a "special" case of more general brushless DC motors. You can drive them with purely analog signals so the only electrical noise is at the drive frequency (Hz to hundreds of Hz typically).

You're way too vague on what is actually needed to suggest anything. Motion systems have too many dimensions/parameters to say any specific example is "low noise".
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline wizard69

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 1184
  • Country: us
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #11 on: May 24, 2020, 01:38:25 am »
Thank you Mike,
it sounds interesting. I did a search but couldn't find any devices. Can you suggest part numbers or keywords?

Many thanks :)

Does it have to be an electric motor?    There are a variety of air driven motors, hydraulic motors and in a pinch you can find Steam and water driven motors.    It really comes down to what you are doing, for example an air driven motor may provide rotation buy not real holding ability.   If you need to position and hold like a stepper then you couldn't go that route.   examples: https://www.atlascopco.com/en-us/itba/products/air-motors, https://www.mcmaster.com/air-motors    Some of those motors listed in the McMaster-Carr catalog show up in many Amish and Mennonite shops and farms.   Their concerns are not electrical noise but an air line can offer a lot of isolation between whatever is your concern and the controls.   

Just out of the box back on the farm thinking there.

Beyond that I really don't think modern stepper controller are advisable.   You may need to take a step backwards to avoid the current limit switching of modern drivers.   For example a driver with resistor current limiting.   It really depends upon Where your electrical noise concerns are, is it audible noise, greater than 1MHz or something else.
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline ricko_ukTopic starter

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 1158
  • Country: gb
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #12 on: May 24, 2020, 01:44:18 am »
Thank you wizard69 and Someone,
don't know much about motors apart from the basics. All I need to understand/find-out is what type of motor is best suited (brushless DC, stepper, etc).

The only requirements are:
- must be electrical
- max voltage available on the board: 12V
- as low noise as possible in terms of amplitude as well as frequency spectrum (this is as specific as I can get)
- drive speed 1 RPM to 200 RPM that I can control through a micro
- load/torque next minimal as I only have to rotate a 200 grams plastic disk. It can take few seconds to accelerate, it doesn't matter.

That's all that is required. And all I need is to understand what is the type of motor with the lowest electrical noise (again, in terms of amplitude as well as frequency spectrum). Would it be a stepper with some slew rate device (after some Googling still no idea what they are) like NiHaoMike suggested or some other motor types?

Thank you
« Last Edit: May 24, 2020, 01:46:44 am by ricko_uk »
 

Offline Someone

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 5156
  • Country: au
    • send complaints here
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #13 on: May 24, 2020, 05:17:11 am »
Thank you wizard69 and Someone,
don't know much about motors apart from the basics. All I need to understand/find-out is what type of motor is best suited (brushless DC, stepper, etc).

The only requirements are:
- must be electrical
- max voltage available on the board: 12V
- as low noise as possible in terms of amplitude as well as frequency spectrum (this is as specific as I can get)
- drive speed 1 RPM to 200 RPM that I can control through a micro
- load/torque next minimal as I only have to rotate a 200 grams plastic disk. It can take few seconds to accelerate, it doesn't matter.

That's all that is required. And all I need is to understand what is the type of motor with the lowest electrical noise (again, in terms of amplitude as well as frequency spectrum). Would it be a stepper with some slew rate device (after some Googling still no idea what they are) like NiHaoMike suggested or some other motor types?

Thank you
The bolded part is going to constantly prevent any sensible suggestions or analysis. There are extremely low noise (electrically) methods that would either put large magnetic fields, or concentrate all the "noise" to a very narrow frequency band. You have left too many dimensions unconstrained without anything to weigh/trade against. Hence the suggestions above for clockwork or hydraulic drives. A hydraulic servo keeps all the electrical noise away from the drive location, but may have more noise overall.
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline beanflying

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 7375
  • Country: au
  • Toys so very many Toys.
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #14 on: May 24, 2020, 05:27:28 am »
Thank you wizard69 and Someone,
don't know much about motors apart from the basics. All I need to understand/find-out is what type of motor is best suited (brushless DC, stepper, etc).

The only requirements are:
- must be electrical
- max voltage available on the board: 12V
- as low noise as possible in terms of amplitude as well as frequency spectrum (this is as specific as I can get)
- drive speed 1 RPM to 200 RPM that I can control through a micro
- load/torque next minimal as I only have to rotate a 200 grams plastic disk. It can take few seconds to accelerate, it doesn't matter.

That's all that is required. And all I need is to understand what is the type of motor with the lowest electrical noise (again, in terms of amplitude as well as frequency spectrum). Would it be a stepper with some slew rate device (after some Googling still no idea what they are) like NiHaoMike suggested or some other motor types?

Thank you

You will not get that sort of turndown ratio without a two stage (at least) mechanical reduction. EDIT What you might get will be in the order of 20-200 RPM or maybe a bit better in particular if you kick it higher then come back down in speed.

Steppers will be electrically noisy to hell along with their drivers so I wouldn't consider them either.

For Quality motors the likes of https://www.maxongroup.co.uk/maxon/view/catalog are great but by no means cheap. Give them your application and see what they offer.  :)
« Last Edit: May 24, 2020, 05:38:26 am by beanflying »
Coffee, Food, R/C and electronics nerd in no particular order. Also CNC wannabe, 3D printer and Laser Cutter Junkie and just don't mention my TEA addiction....
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Online Ian.M

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 13218
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #15 on: May 24, 2020, 07:17:31 am »
If you don't give a flying **** about efficiency and are willing to have a big heatsink for the drive output stage,  consider a RC hobby sensorless BLDC gimbal motor, driven open loop as a PM synchronous motor with smooth AC currents from three linear class B amplifiers, each with a current feedback loop so it acts as a power voltage controlled current source/sink.  Generate the control voltage signals using three 12 bit DACs, fed with data from an approximate sinewave* lookup table in a MCU using software DDS techniques to generate three phases at 120 deg separation, at frequencies from DC up to 3.333 * N_poles Hz for direct drive.  Control frequency ramp-up/ramp-down to limit the acceleration so the motor doesn't slip out of synchronous operation as there is no provision to resynchronise.

There will be minimal electrical noise from the motor and drive amplifiers, and most of that will be at the drive frequency and first few harmonics, so as long as you can screen the magnetic field from the motor and minimise the wiring loop area, provided the digital side is very well screened and its supply and the DAC outputs are well filtered, EMI shouldn't be a problem for all except the most demanding applications.

* Due to the winding pattern of a BLDC motor, the lookup table probably wont be an ideal sinewave, but may need to be pre-distorted to minimise cogging, to get a more linear relationship between LUT pointer and rotor physical position.   Drive the motor shaft at  a  fairly high speed so it generates, connect a heavy resistive load and scope the coil waveforms to get an idea of the required waveform shape!
« Last Edit: May 24, 2020, 07:24:01 am by Ian.M »
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline filssavi

  • Frequent Contributor
  • **
  • Posts: 433
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #16 on: May 24, 2020, 07:21:02 am »
For the lowest EMC I would use a fixed speed three phase induction machine directly connected to the grid (No VFD), and then use a CVT transmission to vary the speed, I would also push the machine as far away from your load as humanely possible with a belt or chain To connect it to the transmission box

If you NEED an all electric solution (which is the worst in term of noise) there is no avoiding a VFD, and in that case it’s all degrees of bad, steppers and DC machines are god awful piles of junk spewing EMI from DC to light (sometimes literally)
 BLDCs are less awful but still bad, the best are PMSM and Induction machines (avoid slip rings though, as they might arc with vibration and wear). Now the problem is the VFD, first and foremost buy the best one you can afford (bonus points if it is a CSU inverter, if you manage to find it small enough) put it as far away from anything sensitive as possible (realistically at least in another room, better still if in another building) use the best, most expensive shielded cables you can find and afford, you will still need to filter the crap out of the VFD output, I would say allocate a sizeable chunk of the budget to it (let’s say 25 to 50% of the overall budget, skimp on the machine instead if you really need to) You will want a very large series inductor for low pass, tens to hundreds of millihenry at least, it will need to be custom designed to minimise parasitic capacitance, otherwise high frequencies will pass straight through, so it will be physically large, heavy and very expensive, this will also smooth out the pwm to sinusoids, then you follow it up with as many stages of traditional common and differential mode filtering as needed to get the required performance. The efficiency will be atrocious, however there is not much you can do about that without compromising on EMI


Now when it’s all said and you will have a system that is worse off in pretty much any way imaginable to a hydraulic one
- more expensive
- bigger
- heavier
- not much more efficient
- noisier(in emi terms)
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline nfmax

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 1624
  • Country: gb
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #17 on: May 24, 2020, 07:44:51 am »
If the diameter of the turntable is large enough, you can use a flexible belt drive, as your torque and acceleration requirements are low. A speed reduction of 100:1 should be feasible. This is how they did it in record player turntables back in the day, though the primary concern was mechanical noise rather than electrical. Both shaded pole induction motors and BLDC motors were used.

With a suitably large moment of inertia, would it possible to simply turn the motor off briefly while you make your measurements, and let the turntable 'coast'?
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline beanflying

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 7375
  • Country: au
  • Toys so very many Toys.
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #18 on: May 24, 2020, 07:55:06 am »
If the diameter of the turntable is large enough, you can use a flexible belt drive, as your torque and acceleration requirements are low. A speed reduction of 100:1 should be feasible. This is how they did it in record player turntables back in the day, though the primary concern was mechanical noise rather than electrical. Both shaded pole induction motors and BLDC motors were used.

With a suitably large moment of inertia, would it possible to simply turn the motor off briefly while you make your measurements, and let the turntable 'coast'?

He wants a turndown rate from 1-200 RPM which is not feasible with a single reduction.
Coffee, Food, R/C and electronics nerd in no particular order. Also CNC wannabe, 3D printer and Laser Cutter Junkie and just don't mention my TEA addiction....
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline Siwastaja

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 9336
  • Country: fi
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #19 on: May 24, 2020, 08:07:51 am »
Obviously, brushless, called BLDC or PMAC. Stepper motor is brushless, as well.

Designing the inverter (or motor controller, or driver, many names for the same thing; applies for steppers, as well) yourself allows sacrificing a tiny bit of efficiency to slow down switching, reducing EMI. Keep the layout tight and place the inverter as close as the motor as possible, it could be a small PCB right at the motor terminals.

For such low-torque, low-speed application requiring precision speed, stepper motor is the most obvious choice. If higher range of speeds, and/or high torque is needed, then BLDC+gearbox.

I have designed a class AB sine-wave microstepping stepper driver once for the absolute lowest EMI (overengineering, no actual specification nor actual EMI problem, just wanted to do it), but usually you wouldn't do that.
« Last Edit: May 24, 2020, 12:15:42 pm by Siwastaja »
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline Someone

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 5156
  • Country: au
    • send complaints here
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #20 on: May 24, 2020, 09:52:38 am »
If the diameter of the turntable is large enough, you can use a flexible belt drive, as your torque and acceleration requirements are low. A speed reduction of 100:1 should be feasible. This is how they did it in record player turntables back in the day, though the primary concern was mechanical noise rather than electrical. Both shaded pole induction motors and BLDC motors were used.

With a suitably large moment of inertia, would it possible to simply turn the motor off briefly while you make your measurements, and let the turntable 'coast'?

He wants a turndown rate from 1-200 RPM which is not feasible with a single reduction.
When you open up design concepts (and your mind) a little, its not hard at all to meet those speed requirements with direct drive.... coming from experience putting precision motion right on top of low noise electronic sensing.
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline beanflying

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 7375
  • Country: au
  • Toys so very many Toys.
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #21 on: May 24, 2020, 10:28:50 am »
If the diameter of the turntable is large enough, you can use a flexible belt drive, as your torque and acceleration requirements are low. A speed reduction of 100:1 should be feasible. This is how they did it in record player turntables back in the day, though the primary concern was mechanical noise rather than electrical. Both shaded pole induction motors and BLDC motors were used.

With a suitably large moment of inertia, would it possible to simply turn the motor off briefly while you make your measurements, and let the turntable 'coast'?

He wants a turndown rate from 1-200 RPM which is not feasible with a single reduction.
When you open up design concepts (and your mind) a little, its not hard at all to meet those speed requirements with direct drive.... coming from experience putting precision motion right on top of low noise electronic sensing.

When you consider the 'low noise' part of it initially requested it limits the options. If you ignore it then a stepper/gearbox makes a lot of sense but they are a long way from low noise.

So rather than 'open your mind' then offer ZERO how about you make a suggestion?
Coffee, Food, R/C and electronics nerd in no particular order. Also CNC wannabe, 3D printer and Laser Cutter Junkie and just don't mention my TEA addiction....
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline Someone

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 5156
  • Country: au
    • send complaints here
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #22 on: May 24, 2020, 12:30:52 pm »
If the diameter of the turntable is large enough, you can use a flexible belt drive, as your torque and acceleration requirements are low. A speed reduction of 100:1 should be feasible. This is how they did it in record player turntables back in the day, though the primary concern was mechanical noise rather than electrical. Both shaded pole induction motors and BLDC motors were used.

With a suitably large moment of inertia, would it possible to simply turn the motor off briefly while you make your measurements, and let the turntable 'coast'?
He wants a turndown rate from 1-200 RPM which is not feasible with a single reduction.
When you open up design concepts (and your mind) a little, its not hard at all to meet those speed requirements with direct drive.... coming from experience putting precision motion right on top of low noise electronic sensing.
When you consider the 'low noise' part of it initially requested it limits the options. If you ignore it then a stepper/gearbox makes a lot of sense but they are a long way from low noise.

So rather than 'open your mind' then offer ZERO how about you make a suggestion?
Because there are too many variables/parameters to make any serious suggestions. What constitutes "noise"? A single pole rotor (permanent magnet) could be driven to the specifications required with electronics similar to an audio amplifier, almost zero EMI but likely huge magnetic fringing fields. An ultrasonic motor would do it with no audible noise. Both without any gearing as direct drive. If every concept of "noise" is sensitive then the suggestions already provided of hydraulics are valid.

"noise" is even less clear than "low", together they're just marketing speak.
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline T3sl4co1l

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 22436
  • Country: us
  • Expert, Analog Electronics, PCB Layout, EMC
    • Seven Transistor Labs
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #23 on: May 24, 2020, 12:37:34 pm »
Float the turntable on water (or other hydraulic bearing), embed a bar magnet in it, and drive two coils in quadrature to position it.  Drive can be via DAC into linear power amp, so the digital MCU control stuff can be at some distance (use isolation?) from the amplifier and compass\\\\motor.

You know, like they did it two centuries ago. ;D ;D

Tim
Seven Transistor Labs, LLC
Electronic design, from concept to prototype.
Bringing a project to life?  Send me a message!
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk

Offline filssavi

  • Frequent Contributor
  • **
  • Posts: 433
Re: Lowest electrical noise type of motor for low speed applications
« Reply #24 on: May 24, 2020, 04:07:37 pm »
BLD
Float the turntable on water (or other hydraulic bearing), embed a bar magnet in it, and drive two coils in quadrature to position it.  Drive can be via DAC into linear power amp, so the digital MCU control stuff can be at some distance (use isolation?) from the amplifier and compass\\\\motor.

You know, like they did it two centuries ago. ;D ;D

Tim

What you are suggesting is a poor man BLDC, then he might just as well use a proper one...

The problem with BLDCs is that, similarly to steppers they are usually driven By fully energising a phase at a time, that  has its advantages (mainly its cheap) But will generate quite a lot of noise. The least noisy way to drive a machine is with sinusoids (ok it is not that simple I know but let’s not go too much into details) so PMSM (also knows as BLAC) or induction machines

Also the placement for the MCU is completely irrelevant, as the machine drive and machine themselves will spew out much much more EMI

Last but not least I would strongly Advice against rolling your own drive, as if you don’t have experience in the field it is pretty much guaranteed you will fail even the most basic compliance test, let alone do better than what you find on the market

Also provided you are willing to spend I am sure you can find off the shelf solutions to the problem as your problem is common in many T&M specialities
 
The following users thanked this post: ricko_uk


Share me

Digg  Facebook  SlashDot  Delicious  Technorati  Twitter  Google  Yahoo
Smf