If you apply that logic, none of your mains equipment should be considered safe, regardless of any UL or TUV approvals.
None? A lot of mains double insulated equipment is not safe. Just one example. A double insulated drill with a metallic chuck and gearbox can be (and is) approved. In normal use an operator will have one hand on the metal part of the drill, yes he is double insulated from the drills cord but he is far more at risk if drilling through a live cable than if he was using a tool with a fully earthed frame.
I don't see how that offers any protection at all. If the insulation between the primary and secondary fails, the metallic blot would provide no protection at all.
Of course not, hell it's much safer to have any metal adjacent a mains winding floating from ground? </sarcasm>
We're not talking about a fixed installation but a portable appliance. I despute that claim otherwise IT (floating mains) installations wouldn't be allowed in places like hospitals. If I remember rightly, a floating secondary is allowed but it's advisable to fit an insulation monitoring device to issue a warning in case of a fault. 12V halogen lighting is powered from a transformer with an unearthed secondary. It's known as SELV, Separated (meaning not earthed), Extra Low Voltage (under 50VAC).
Just a portable appliance, projects are only portable appliances?
The same physics apply regardless of the source of supply. Or does a mains plug offer some magic control of of all that passes through it?
Not questioning your memory but our rules which have a basis from an old copy of our rules are quite specific in terms of earthing a secondary. Nothing short of an engineers sign off and type approval allows anything different. The latter of course unfortunately can be purchased for a fee for almost any piece of imported rubbish.
Unearthed halogen lighting falls into the same categories, type approved appliance or fixed wiring out of reach. Check the sections on earthing of exposed luminaires there is no specific exclusion for ELV lamps fed from mains transformers. The fact they generally don't get done doesn't imply any assumed safety margin.
And here in the UK it's mandatory for all plug sockets in the bathroom to be powered by an isolation transformer with a floating secondary.
That's both dumb and expensive. There are many much more effective ways of reducing the risk of electrocution in damp situations.
Not true, all that's required is the secondary be double insulated from the primary, BS EN 60742. If it isn't you need to earth the secondary.
Ah blind faith and regulations. Of course we all know that double insulation can never break down and BS-whatever will keep use safe from harm. Double insulation is not a miracle cure.
If the reinforced insulation can be broken that easily, it shouldn't be approved.
Agreed! This doesn't however make all that garbage out there in the marketplace, or any of those low cost parts shop transformers any more safe. I've seen live mains flashed across abused power bricks more times than I'd like to remember and seen more than the odd transformer meltdown/burnout.
We are primarily talking home built DIY projects here. The home constructor does not have the testing resources necessary to test and rate double insulation. It's just common sense to soundly earth anything metallic part or chassis of any project with even the remotest possibility of being touched or coming in contact with a loose wire or burnt winding.
I'd think damaging the case would expose the user to live parts before shorting the secondary to the primary. All the insulation between primary and secondary is inside the device sealed in a plastic box which would have to be badly damaged to cause it to fail.
I could show you numerous examples where this has not been the case. Badly damaged yes, but often with internal damage hidden by a battered but still intact outer casing. You've never seen plastic PCB pillars snap and come adrift within appliances?