Electronics > Projects, Designs, and Technical Stuff

Two IR LEDs in series, powered by 18650

(1/3) > >>

Peabody:
A while back I built an IR remote for my Roku box.  It used a single LED and a Darlington transistor, with everything powered directly (no regulator) by an 18650.  The Darlington was probably not a good idea, and I've thought about modifying the circuit  to replace it with a mosfet.  But I also wondered about using a second LED in series with the first one, so as much battery power as possible would be converted into signal power instead of just wasting it as heat in current-limiting resistors.  The attached circuit is where I am at the moment.  The LEDs would probably be Vishay TSAL6100, and the mosfet would be one of those SOT-23 jobs with vanishingly small RDSon.

But I wonder if this is a practical design.  It seems the current is going to vary a lot depending on the battery's charge state.  Has anyone here done something like this?  Does it seem to work ok?

Also, I'm assuming the Arduino GPIO could drive the mosfet gate at 38K without issues.  Does that seem right?  I guess it would depend on gate capacitance?

Anyway, before I start ordering parts, any comments or suggestions would be appreciated.


Buriedcode:
I don't see why using two IR emitters in series would be a problem, their Vf is 1.6V max, so would still be fine when your 18650 is <3.2V.   Of course as your battery voltage decreases, their output will, but this isn't that easy to work out by how much as their forward voltage will decrease with decreasing current.  Also, as its a remote, almost all protocols have relatively low duty cycles, both to save the batteries in the remote, and to allow for higher peak power, increasing the remotes range.

For arguments sake, lets say your 18650 is fully charged to 4.2V.   And the Vf worst case for the emitters is 1.4V.  4.2 - (2*1.4) / 4.7 = ~300mA through the emitters.  That isn't massive wit regard to a lot of remotes.  Many common remotes have a single emitter, running off two alkaline cells, with a 10-22R resistor.

One thing I would check, preferably actually test, is the MOSFET's turn on time.  I have used several of the modern wonders that are SOT23 MOSFETS with single, or just double digit miliohm on resistance.  They *tend* to have quite long turn on/off times, as well has higher gate capacitance (I saying higher because plenty have tiny gate capacitance so work nicely up to hundreds of kHz).  The carrier is 38kHz, but for reasons above might not be 50% duty.  Say its 25%, for a carrier period of 26.3us, the pulse width is ~6.6us.  As the GPIO will be limited in its driving capability that 6.6us has to take into account not just the turn-on delay, but the gate charging.

You could probably simulate it in LTspice, as there are plenty of MOSFETs models in there.  Ultimately, though, its not like you're stunting amps here, or constantly transmitting for minutes at a time - I can't see anything popping, it just might produce a carrier with a low duty cycle.  But things to think about!  If in doubt, knock up a dirty prototype and test/measure.  Discretes are so cheap you probably have to order 10 at a time anyway.

Doctorandus_P:
Voltage drop of LED's varies a lot with the color of the LED. IR LED's can be at around 1V (and temperature depentent etc).

If you put shunt resistor R1 on the Bottom side of the IR LED's you can put a bipolar transistor over it that pulls the gate to GND as a current limit, but make sure first that Ugs of the FET is low enough to tolerate the 600mV lower voltage drop.

Also:
For Bipolar transistors Ube is relatively constant at around 600mV, but in saturation the Collector can drop to as low as 50mV to 200mV above the Base. Sometimes bipolar transistors circuits are switching faster by placing a scottky diode over the Base and Collector, which pulls away the base current when the collector is nearing saturation.

Peabody:

--- Quote from: Doctorandus_P on June 12, 2020, 05:40:48 am ---
If you put shunt resistor R1 on the Bottom side of the IR LED's you can put a bipolar transistor over it that pulls the gate to GND as a current limit, but make sure first that Ugs of the FET is low enough to tolerate the 600mV lower voltage drop.

Also:
For Bipolar transistors Ube is relatively constant at around 600mV, but in saturation the Collector can drop to as low as 50mV to 200mV above the Base. Sometimes bipolar transistors circuits are switching faster by placing a scottky diode over the Base and Collector, which pulls away the base current when the collector is nearing saturation.

--- End quote ---

Thanks very much, but I should have said at the outset that I am not formally trained in this stuff.  Could you possibly post a hand drawing illustrating these suggestions?

Peabody:

--- Quote from: Buriedcode on June 12, 2020, 03:15:44 am ---
For arguments sake, lets say your 18650 is fully charged to 4.2V.   And the Vf worst case for the emitters is 1.4V.  4.2 - (2*1.4) / 4.7 = ~300mA through the emitters.  That isn't massive wit regard to a lot of remotes.  Many common remotes have a single emitter, running off two alkaline cells, with a 10-22R resistor.

--- End quote ---

What I have now is a single emitter, a Darlington, and a 10R resistor.  But I had forgotten that a Darlington doesn't fully saturate, and there is always a one-diode drop across it.  So while it "wastes" less base current, it makes up for that by dissipating that diode drop on the full load current.  So then I thought maybe just a regular NPN, but they still have some drop at saturation, and wasted base current (wasted in the sense that the base current doesn't flow through the LED).  So I thought a mosfet would essentially eliminate any drop in the LED circuit, and would only waste whatever is needed to deal with gate capacitance (which, however, as you point out, could be significant).  The thing is - adding the second emitter is as close as I'll ever get to a "free lunch" in electronics. You get twice the IR power on the same current.  Well, not free in terms of cost and parts count, but you know what I mean.

What do most remotes use - a mosfet or bipolar?  I've only had one that I remember having two emitters, and it was a universal remote.


--- Quote ---You could probably simulate it in LTspice, as there are plenty of MOSFETs models in there. 

--- End quote ---

Well, I'm an amateur, and have never done LTspice.  I guess I should look at that at some point.

Thanks very much for your comments.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

There was an error while thanking
Thanking...
Go to full version
Powered by SMFPacks Advanced Attachments Uploader Mod