1
Repair / Re: Which USB3-SATA dock/cradle/adapter for 3.5+2.5" hdds without 4K/sec emulation?
« Last post by fzabkar on Today at 11:37:00 am »There is no such thing as a "good dock" or a "bad dock". Some will present a fixed 512-byte physical sector size to the USB host while others will present a fixed 4KB physical sector size. Still others will use 512-byte sectoring for drives with a capacity less than 2TiB, and automatically switch to 4KB sectoring for drives larger than 2TiB.
The reason for this behaviour is so that large drives can be used with legacy OS-es such as Windows XP. Since Win XP is limited to MBR partitions, the maximum number of sectors it can address is 2^32. At 512 bytes per sector, that works out to a capacity of 2TiB. However, if the sector size is increased to 4KB (= 8 x 512B), then XP can see a USB mass storage device with a capacity of 16TiB. This was how Seagate approached this problem with their early external drives. WD's My Book externals can be "fast formatted" to present either sector size to the host.
Note that these USB bridges behave the same way whether the drive is a 512n (native) or 512e (emulated) model. That is, it has nothing to do with whether the drive is an Advanced Format model with 4KB physical sectors.
The reason for this behaviour is so that large drives can be used with legacy OS-es such as Windows XP. Since Win XP is limited to MBR partitions, the maximum number of sectors it can address is 2^32. At 512 bytes per sector, that works out to a capacity of 2TiB. However, if the sector size is increased to 4KB (= 8 x 512B), then XP can see a USB mass storage device with a capacity of 16TiB. This was how Seagate approached this problem with their early external drives. WD's My Book externals can be "fast formatted" to present either sector size to the host.
Note that these USB bridges behave the same way whether the drive is a 512n (native) or 512e (emulated) model. That is, it has nothing to do with whether the drive is an Advanced Format model with 4KB physical sectors.