1
General Technical Chat / Re: Do you think an LED is a resistor?
« Last post by Berni on Today at 05:54:00 pm »There is so much to unpack here but let's consider only the last part.
A capacitor at DC can hold a voltage without passing current; try to do that with a resistor.
An inductor at DC can hold a current without a voltage (if ideal, and a small voltage due to small resistive losses if real). Try to do that with a resistor.
You can use these properties to create memory cells. Try to do that with resistors alone.
I am not well versed in memristors to give an elementary setting that shows their fundamental difference from resistors, but I am pretty confident you got that part wrong, as well.
Have you looked up the Science Direct link I gave above? I am not redefining industry standard terms: diodes have been considered to be nonlinear resistors for decades. You just wasn't aware of it.
Yes and we have names for a resistive device that is designed to be very non linear, the industry standard term for that is a varistor instead of resistor.
If you just generalise all these things are being resistors, then you could also generalize all diodes as diodes (even tho they act very differently), then it falls apart even more as some TVS diodes exhibit a memrisor like behavior (they clamp down and stay clamped until you reduce the current, hence have memory of previous current). But that's besides the point. Diodes exhibiting electrical resistance is nothing special or ground breaking. Everyone in this thread knows about it.
The only problem is that you are throwing around the term resistor and resistance as being the same thing. They are not. The resistor is the industry standard term for a device that is designed to create the effect of resistance in a well defined manner. While electrical resistance is a physics phenomenon where something opposes the flow of current in a electrical circuit.
What is the point you are trying to make with this thread? That a diode has electrical resistance? Or that everything that exhibits electrical resistance should be called a resistor?