As stated above, you can get excessive screen current if there is no plate voltage present.
It would take a few times my calculation of 100 mA to blow the 5 W resistor, but your power supply can probably support that.
With zero grid bias (again, as stated above), the cathode current is excessive and may have blown something in the plate supply (although you have tested the transformer, perhaps there is something in the power supply that could blow).
The combination of zero G1 bias and no plate voltage could well be fatal to the resistors.
The nice thing about octal tubes is that they are hard to plug-in incorrectly, unless you have broken the key on the tube base.
(There are some equivalents to the 6L6 with a different pin-out, such as the 6BG6 with plate cap and different base connections.)