Thanks for replying. I tried what you said, changing out the potentiometer to a new one, and I also changed out an LM358 op-amp on the output board. Following the tests, working with a a suitable load and increasing the current slowly, I didn't observe a jump, though now I'm not sure if it was the potentiometer or the op-amp that was the problem. Either way, as I increased the current up to 9 amps due to the resistor, I didn't see any jumps so I think everything works out well.
Thanks for the help. I really appreciate it. I'm just glad this nightmare is over. If you don't mind me asking some questions, I'd like to get some advice from you regarding what you said and on another issue as well.
First, you theorized that the pot may have been repeatedly set/adjusted around this 3A limit causing some wear and tear. What are some good practices to prevent this from happening, or is this just something that happens as you move parts/knobs back and forth?
Second, with my link to the schematic below, I was wondering what you thought of the various black and white shapes littered throughout schematic? Parts aside, the shapes seem to represent connections to the other boards, but they don't seem to always be at the edge. Do you think the shapes are 1-to-1 with black # matching with black #, or black # matching with corresponding white #? It just felt kind of strange seeing these shapes, and it's hard to keep track of throughout the board, but it would be nice to know just in case this power supply breaks again.