I would have replaced the charred resistor as well. Yes, I implemented this technique at work. I bought a Flir One Pro and a refurbished IPad with a lightning cable and created a “database” of normal temperatures for a variety of boards. For some boards, we reduced the troubleshooting times to nothing. For others, not so much. You need a resistance that dissipate heat. A dead short doesn’t heat up.
Anyway, OT, my daughter has a Spectre for about 5 years, probably one of the best laptops out there. Features, speed , battery life, she loved it. The battery life started going down significantly lately but otherwise, a great laptop.