"Universal Car Soldering Aid Pliers" -- any good?

[ledtester]

Has anyone had experience using the "Universal Car Soldering Aid Pliers", e.g.:

https://www.amazon.com/Camrusic-Soldering-Automobile-Maintenance-Repairing/dp/B0BSGG7T3G/

or

https://www.aliexpress.us/item/3256805286425401.html

Looks like it could be handy for soldering wires together.

[alm]

It doesn't look to me like it has any way of clamping the wires, so I'd think it only works for stiff, fairly thick wires like shown in the picture.

[BlackICE]

Seems to use spring clamps on the jaws to hold the wires.

[BradC]

Of course none of us would ever solder a joint like that and rely on the solder for mechanical strength now would we? 

[BlackICE]

Of course not. Even if the wire were looped and hooked then twisted together the solder joint and surrounding area should never be subject to movement or vibration anyway, because repeated movement will fatigue the wire causing failure. So the strength of the solder joint shouldn't be as big of a deal as one would expect. I would guess if you just laid 20x+ the diameter of the wire side by side and soldered it together correctly, then did a straight pull test the solder joint will not fail. One of the sides right near the joint will break 1st. The weakened heated copper will fail 1st.

[Berni]

This is useless for soldering wires together on a workbench. For that all you need is something to hold one end of a wire.

But the one thing i could see this tool useful for is joining wires together in the field when working in tight spaces. Like soldering a wiring loom that already has both ends of a wire mounted in place in some hole on a car or boat or something. You can't pull the wire out of the hole to do soldering comfortably This lets you manipulate both ends of the wire without having to stick your whole hand in there, leaving lots of room to come in with a soldering iron. Especialy since you want to get your wires nicely parallel, otherwise it is hard to get heatshrink over it, or the sharp point could puncture trough the heatshrink.

[thm_w]

This is useless for soldering wires together on a workbench. For that all you need is something to hold one end of a wire.

You need to hold both ends in some cases, eg if one end has a heavy connector, the other is a harness, using stiff wire, etc.
Then you'll have one hand free to feed in solder.

[Someone]

This is useless for soldering wires together on a workbench. For that all you need is something to hold one end of a wire.

You need to hold both ends in some cases, eg if one end has a heavy connector, the other is a harness, using stiff wire, etc.
Then you'll have one hand free to feed in solder.

and not form micro cracks from vibration/movement as the solder is cooling to solidus.

[Berni]

This is useless for soldering wires together on a workbench. For that all you need is something to hold one end of a wire.

You need to hold both ends in some cases, eg if one end has a heavy connector, the other is a harness, using stiff wire, etc.
Then you'll have one hand free to feed in solder.

Yep in that case i put the connector into a mini vise to keep it steady.

Usually i pre tin both ends before soldering so not feeding in fresh flux filled solder is not as important. The pre tining leaves enough stray flux on the wire to make a decent looking joint as long as you do it fast. If it still doesn't want to make a nice joint i can always add a tiny bit of gel flux on the end of the wire.

For just holding wires still when soldering i tend to use the PCBite clamps. They are only really designed to hold PCBs but they grab wires nicely too and because of squeezing it over a large area it doesn't damage the insulation (especially when it gets soft from the heat of the soldering). But the classical "3rd hand" jigs work well too once you put some heatshrink on the crocodiles to prevent them from biting into the insulation.

[freda]

just imagine what we could do if humans evolved with 3 arms and hands!!
we would probably be already traveling right across the galaxy.lol

[Gyro]

just imagine what we could do if humans evolved with 3 arms and hands!!
we would probably be already traveling right across the galaxy.lol

Nature doesn't like asymetry, so better to evolve four - two for the objects, one for the iron and one for the solder. A simpler leap would be more evolved feet and with opposible 'thumbs' (we may already have this, like the tree climbing apes) and improved, probably just trained, leg flexibility. This could be be accompanied by a modified and enlarged ass structure for greater stability (a proportion of the population have already developed this!).

[Stray Electron]

just imagine what we could do if humans evolved with 3 arms and hands!!
we would probably be already traveling right across the galaxy.lol

  Probably not IMO. Our lack of physical strength and agility is exactly what forced humans to become more intelligent than other animals and forced us to develop tools and forced us to develop language so that we could work as a group to solve problems.

[tooki]

Has anyone had experience using the "Universal Car Soldering Aid Pliers", e.g.:

https://www.amazon.com/Camrusic-Soldering-Automobile-Maintenance-Repairing/dp/B0BSGG7T3G/

or

https://www.aliexpress.us/item/3256805286425401.html

Looks like it could be handy for soldering wires together.

Cool idea, but since you hold the wires so closely together, I think there’s a big risk of the insulation getting damaged once the wire heats up, especially on thick wire that takes longer to heat up. (Insulation gets soft, jaws squeeze into it.) I use helping hands with silicone tube on the jaws for such things, and try to actually clip the wire far apart and use extra helping hands arms to passively support the wires more carefully into place.

This gives me an idea, though: maybe I could machine holders that are specific to individual insulation diameters, so that the wire is held in a round hole the same size and shape as the insulation, so that even if it softens, it’s kept in the right shape. Hmmm… (I start a new job in September and my lab will be within the mechanical workshop, so I’ll have plenty of access to machines and skill.

[nctnico]

just imagine what we could do if humans evolved with 3 arms and hands!!
we would probably be already traveling right across the galaxy.lol

You've got 5 fingers on each hand. I use two fingers to feed solder and two fingers to hold the wire using one hand.