Hi
Need some help deciding on a VNA, both options are great but you know
I have the option to buy a calibrated HP 8753D / opt. 006 with 6GHz with integrated S-Parameter Test Set, valid calibration or a HP8753C with the HP85047A 6-GHz test Set for 3200 USD vs 2450 USD.
I have of course seen Dr. Kirkby's nice comparison:
https://www.kirkbymicrowave.co.uk/Everything-you-wanted-to-know-about-the-HP-8753-VNA/To sum it up the main differences are:
- Low 30khz range
- 10dB more dynamic range
- Presets
- FIRMWARE (4.13 vs 7.74) so basically the "D" variant was supported until the end! That seems to be a pretty big deal to me but maybe sombody can comment on the details?
- Floppy disk (useful?)
Some subjective differences:
- D version is much more compact (one piece, no adapters)
- More modern look and layout with the modern non clicky soft buttons
Disadvantage of the "D" verison:
- Potentially the APC-7 connectors since adapter seem to cost about 150-200USD
I lean towards the 8753D, not surprisingly