Products > Test Equipment

3478A AC Offset

(1/2) > >>

PA0PBZ:
My 3478A shows a bad offset from zero on AC volts and AC mA. When I short the input and set it to ACV the display shows a steady 0.353 mV. Set to ACA with the input open it shows 0.425 mA, with the input shorted 0.413 mA. Since there is no calibration procedure for zero in the AC ranges I wonder what to do. V and A on DC is ok, but I did the zero calibration anyway. Checked with a DMMCheck it measures OK in DCV and DCA.

alm:
I have written about this on this forum several times, a Google search for true RMS AC offset on the forum should find it. If you read the specs carefully, you will see ACV is only specced from 5-100% of range or so. Are values within that range correct? You should not expect a shorted true RMS ACV meter to read zero, the RMS converter is non-linear for low values. There is a document on the Keithley website that shows that it doesn't significantly affect the accuracy over the specified range. I don't have a link handy, but I linked to it in earlier posts.

PA0PBZ:
Its even worse: Accuracy spec is for >10% of full scale, and then still on the 3V range (20-50Hz) 1.14% + 102(!) digits. AC current also >10% of full scale, 1.54% + 163 digits. I guess that makes it worthless for 1mA measurements  :--

staxquad:

--- Quote from: PA0PBZ on May 24, 2013, 09:07:35 pm ---Its even worse: Accuracy spec is for >10% of full scale, and then still on the 3V range (20-50Hz) 1.14% + 102(!) digits. AC current also >10% of full scale, 1.54% + 163 digits. I guess that makes it worthless for 1mA measurements  :--

--- End quote ---

your excuse to buy a 3458A, no dead zone in the mV AC range  (good to 25microV)

(assume 3478A ~ 34401A for mV AC inaccuracies)



In the graph above, it can be seen that compared to the normalized 3458A data (blue), one of the two 34401As (before and after AC re-calibration) goes very non-linear below about 1 mV and somewhere below 100?V, the 34401A displays a solid noise free 0.000 mV on the 100 mV ACV scale. The red curve is one of the 34401A tests before calibration and the green curve is a test after performing the 1/100th scale calibration on page 84 (page 86 on the pdf file) of the 34401A service manual with the same 34401A. (This graph shows the low end 100 mV AC V performance for the same DMM before and after calibration.)

Also, it is not particularly surprising or even necessarily a bad thing that an instrument in this mid level performance class apparently has such limitations. Designing low cost autoranging AC RMS voltage measurement circuits that can perform near zero is an extremely difficult problem.

from http://www.gellerlabs.com/Articles-Notes/34401A%20AC%20zero.pdf

robrenz:
Exerpt from this related thread.  Notice the shorted ACV value.

8846A AC volts 10mV and below
This is a very crude test but I think it is still valuable.
Rigol 1022 signal generator  with sine wave output at 1KHz feeding a 100 Ohm 10 turn pot as a voltage divider.
Adjusted the Rigol impedance setting so the displayed 2V output equals an actual 2V across the 100 Ohm pot.
Adjusted the voltage divider to get 100:1 attenuation, 2V on Rigol = 0.02V out of the voltage divider. (Rigol only goes to 2mVrms)
Shorted inputs give total min max span of 2.73uV with a SD of .7uV  (noise floor)
These readings are non zeroed but remember I set my voltage divider ratio with the meter.
meter is in 6.5 digit mode with 100NPLC and analog filter on.
Stepped the Rigol down thru the voltages and and gave each reading about 5 seconds of settling time.

The data has readings from 10 mV down to 2mV that are not plotted.  The plotted values are from 0.02mV to 1.0mV
The only thing this shows is the 8846A does not show the nonlinearity that the gellerlabs plots show for the 34401 or 34410 and looks like it would be linear right into the noise floor (Rigol stops at 2mV) No accuracy determination can be made from this crude setup but I think the Rigol and voltage divider are linear enough to see if that graph bulge existed or if the meter had a bogus software zero.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page