Products > Test Equipment
Any advantage of an HP 4195A vs SVA1032x VNA ?
(1/1)
PartialDischarge:
I have a Siglent SVA1032x, but I could get my hands on a HP 4195A. The 4195A is limited to 500MHz but goes down to 10Hz.

For those who know this old equipment is there any technical advantage having it vs a modern VNA?
chilternview:
Things I can think of:

- able to do full S parameter measurement (S11, S21, S22, S12) without changing connections.
- flexible as has 2 outputs and 4 inputs, no hardwired directional coupler/splitter
- can display up to 4 traces from 4 separate inputs
- separate impedance measurement as well as vna/spectrum modes
- Able to sweep not just frequency but also power, DC bias can be swept.
- built in BASIC programming

Disadvantages:
- a big heavy beast
- on some settings (narrow RBW) can be very slow.
- needs e.g. 41952 test fixture to provide splitter/directional coupler

THe attached user guide might give some idea on what you can do with it. I find it very useful
simba15:
I may have a HP 41951A Impedance test set available for sale soon.

Let me know If you go the HP Route and are interested.

G0HZU:
I used one of these quite often from about 1990 onwards. The HP 4195A is a very capable and versatile instrument but it can be very slow to make a measurement compared to other instruments. The sweep time in VNA mode is very slow, presumably because it uses an old/slow internal processor.

The ability to measure down to a few Hz sets it apart from many alternatives, even today. Otherwise, it is slow and has limited dynamic range. The HP 4195A can also be used as a spectrum analyser but it is going to be quite slow in this mode too.

I've not used the Siglent SVA1032x, but I get the impression from reviews that it is at its best as a spectrum analyser. The performance in VNA mode is fairly mediocre.
Navigation
Message Index
There was an error while thanking
Thanking...

Go to full version
Powered by SMFPacks Advanced Attachments Uploader Mod