Products > Test Equipment
Buying a scope for measuring RF waveforms
(1/2) > >>
Mike99:
Dear experts

I'm a radio amateur and my main use for a scope is to measure AF and RF waveforms up to 50MHz. I rarely need to examine logic waveforms.

I currently have a venerable Tektronix 2340A which does the job but is big, heavy and noisy and I'd like to replace it with something new.

I'm only a couple of miles from a major UK supplier of test equipment, including Siglent, Rigol and Micsig scopes, and the Siglent SDS 1202X-E is looking attractive. I only need 2 channels and don't want to spend more than £400.

Not being a scope expert I'd like to hear your opinions on whether this will suit my requirements.

Thanks!

Mike
tszaboo:
What's the reason you would want an oscilloscope for such a job, instead of a spectrum analyzer? That's usually not the right job for that task, even if it has FFT, the signal levels for a scope is much higher, the dynamic range is much lower, you don't have 50 Ohm termination on the low frequency scopes, the input capacitance is high and so on. I would guess even an SDR would be better, or a low cost spectrum analyzer.
tggzzz:

--- Quote from: Mike99 on November 01, 2023, 10:37:14 am ---I'm a radio amateur and my main use for a scope is to measure AF and RF waveforms up to 50MHz. I rarely need to examine logic waveforms.

--- End quote ---

Measure what, exactly?

* frequency? A frequency counter will give more accurate results faster
* amplitude? Scopes are only 2% vertical linearity, at best. To that add the effects of the scope's frequency response, the probing technique (especially resonance), scope VSWR (probably 1:1.3, i.e. >2dB) Better to use a power meter or spectrum analyser
* power? See amplitude, especially for low powers
* harmonics? Not a chance with a scope due to non-linearity and/or ADC resolution. A spectrum analyser is much more appropriate.
* modulation? What type, e.g. amplitude, phase, frequency? FM/PM better with a modulation domain analyser which showing frequency vs time. Or an SDRSummary: a scope is a time-domain instrument. RF measurements are usually frequency domain and lower power. Choose the right tool for the job.

Personally, if I had a working scope that does the job, I would spend my money on something that gave me new and different and interesting capabilities.
Mike99:
I already have an SDR with spectrum analyser software, frequency counter, modulation meter, RF millivoltmeter and a power meter. I'm interested in every day general measurements of peak-to-peak amplitude, noisy waveforms, 2-tone tests of SSB transmitter linearity etc. Nothing fancy.

Mike
nctnico:
AFAIK the SDS1202 gives you the most bandwidth for your money.
Navigation
Message Index
Next page
There was an error while thanking
Thanking...

Go to full version
Powered by SMFPacks Advanced Attachments Uploader Mod