Is this a 189 or a 189/II?
How long are you testing it for? It could take a while for the drain to taper off if the supercap isn't charged up.
I think the way to test these during repair is to take the supercap off entirely first, verify that the drain is low, then test your new supercap for leakage, then install it. Some people just leave them off entirely and live with resetting the date/time after every battery change.