EEVblog Electronics Community Forum
Products => Test Equipment => Topic started by: Cali-Sam on September 14, 2014, 02:23:42 pm
-
I was looking into buying a hot air gun like the one Dave reviewed a while back.... The one Dave reviewed was an atten, there are many others on wavy that look exactly like atten but badged under different names like WEP or Youyue.. My question is: are these exactly the same as the atten?
-
I was looking into buying a hot air gun like the one Dave reviewed a while back.... The one Dave reviewed was an atten, there are many others on wavy that look exactly like atten but badged under different names like WEP or Youyue.. My question is: are these exactly the same as the atten?
AFAIK, there are no 110V Atten branded units of that kind. The other ones are virtually identical (possibly by same manufacturer) though there was a thread here about units that uses two different MCU insides (not that it matters).
These units work well but of low quality. You may want to inspect the ground path inside (I did and decided to return and get a used Hakko from ebay).
-
If you aren't hot air reworking stuff all day long, have a look at this unit:
http://www.circuitspecialists.com/csihotgun-2.html (http://www.circuitspecialists.com/csihotgun-2.html)
I've been using one for 5+ years and it's never failed to perform. Easy to adjust temp and air flow for pretty well any common application - heatshrink, reflow, desoldering etc. I've used it for 20+ minutes at a time (continuous reflow temperature air flow) and it's never got hot to hold etc. If mine ever failed I'd buy another immediately. Hard to beat the price if you're in the US.
They aren't always in stock, so I assume they must be pretty popular.
cheers,
george.
-
http://www.circuitspecialists.com/csihotgun-2.html (http://www.circuitspecialists.com/csihotgun-2.html)
What is the box on the wire? Isolating transformer? Controller?
-
The 'box' has a transformer. There's been a few variations of 'that' end. A unit we bought at work (later unit than mine) has a different 'box'.
cheers,
george.
-
I personally like that thing:
http://www.aoyue.com/en/ArticleShow.asp?ArticleID=380 (http://www.aoyue.com/en/ArticleShow.asp?ArticleID=380)
That thing has a steel case and is build quite well, not the average china crap.
No pump in the handpiece => lighter and smaller handpiece => easier to work with
It also has good temperature regulation and variable airflow, nice when working with different nozzles and component sizes, since you want to reduce air flow with small components to avoid blowing them away.
-
I have a Yihua labeled 858D (http://www.ebay.com/itm/261381854267?_trksid=p2060778.m2749.l2649&ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT). It came to my house from an ebay vendor in California for $51.20 (price seems to vary by the day). Mine came with the typical four nozzles and an extra heating element (haven't needed it yet, and I don't know if every unit will have that: I don't remember it as part of the original listing). It is close enough to what Dave reviewed in EEVblog #167 to make no difference to me.
One difference I have noticed is that my unit displays "---" instead of "SLP" once the air shuts off while the handpiece is in the holder.
-
I was looking into buying a hot air gun like the one Dave reviewed a while back.... The one Dave reviewed was an atten, there are many others on wavy that look exactly like atten but badged under different names like WEP or Youyue.. My question is: are these exactly the same as the atten?
While there are many brands of Chinese made hot air rework stations, they are not all the same. They are made by different manufactures with different degrees of quality.
Generally speaking, all the Chinese brands are of low quality. To see what I mean, I encourage you to view Steven Casagrande's Yihua videos (https://www.youtube.com/user/stevencasagrande/search?query=yihua).
The one exception to this is Aoyue (http://www.aoyue.com), whose products are well made, and very well supported in the USA by SRA-Solder.com (http://www.sra-solder.com) in Massachusetts. Before I ever made a purchase at SRA Solder, I called them multiple times with questions and they were always happy to help with very useful answers. I made multiple purchases over the years from SRA Solder, and have had nothing but excellent service. If you ever have a problem with your Aoyue product, the owner of SRA Solder will make sure your problem is resolved to your satisfaction.
I bought my Aoyue 2703A+ All-in-one Digital Hot Air Rework Station (http://sra-solder.com/product.php/6936/1/aoyue_2703a_all_in_one_digital_hot_air_rework_station_110v) from SRA Solder and am quite happy with it. The hot air wand has good temperature regulation, good airflow regulation, good airflow pressure range, a very wide multitude of affordable nozzles (http://sra-solder.com/section.php/52/1/nozzles) to choose from for virtually any application, and relatively low noise (certainly quieter than the Atten 858D Dave Jones demonstrated (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vva2t21sOAs)). Also, I find it easy to use.
You don't have to buy the top- of-the-line model like I did to get a good quality product that fits your needs. SRA Solder offers a range of SMD hot air rework stations (http://sra-solder.com/section.php/26/1/smd_rework_stations) to fit most any budget or soldering need. As of 2014-Sep-15, their prices on SMD hot air rework stations range from USD$79.00 to USD$299.00.
I have 3 main recommendations for choosing a SMD hot air rework station:
- If you are serious about doing electronics, get a digital station instead of an analog one. The price difference is well worth it in benefits that include precision, ease of use, and more.
- Get a unit that has a pump in the control box instead of a unit with a turbine fan in the wand. If the turbine fan fails, you will need to replace the entire station if you can not find a compatible fan with similar specifications as the original fan. If the pump fails, it can be easily repaired with a new pump diaphram (http://sra-solder.com/product.php/6539/0/replacement_diaphragm_for_the_pump) for just USD$12.00 (2 x USD$6.00; they are used in pairs); or, worst case, with a new pump (http://sra-solder.com/product.php/7073/0/replacement_pump_for_968_968a) for USD$32.00. Also, the pump is quieter.
- If you are interested in a Chinese brand, or do not want to spend a lot of money and still get good quality on a SMD hot air rework or soldering station, make sure you get a genuine Aoyue product, and not a cheap copy.
Full disclosure: I do not work for SRA Solder, nor do I have any financial association with them. I do not work for Aoyue, nor do I have any financial association with them.
-
I've had an Aoyue 968A for several years that's both a 60W soldering station and hot air station. It's been flawless. Stuart at SRA redefines customer service. I'd rather pick up the phone and call him to order something then bother looking for some other product a bit cheaper. He's usually at the best price anyway. Extremely knowledgeable of his products like the above poster says. I wound up buying an X-tronic preheater because Aoyue has changed their board holder on most of their models to the X type rather then the clamps on a rail. Units change frequently and the one I bought seemed to be built just as well as the Aoyue and near identical except for the black anodized finish. Seems like a lot of folks are quite happy with this company too. I can't speak for their stations, but the preheater is nice and customer support superlative also.
In the states, ATTEN soldering stations and hot air station product line are branded Madel as the primary distributor unless they are sold as an OEM product like MCM's stations. My other, smaller pre-heater that's forced air and a knockoff of an earlier Hakko is made by ATTEN, but labled Tenema.
If you do buy a hot air station, get a preheater base. I'm sure that by now, you can get one reasonably priced that has the ability to program a stepped thermal profile and have a second thermocouple sensor to measure the board.