Products > Test Equipment
How do the features in old VNAs and SAs differ from new ones?
G0HZU:
--- Quote from: baldurn on March 15, 2024, 07:49:15 pm ---
--- Quote from: G0HZU on March 15, 2024, 07:19:13 pm ---So in this respect there isn't even a contest. The HP is a different class of VNA because it is a full 2 port VNA. The Siglent SA/VNA doesn't qualify for the contest because it's just a T/R VNA.
--- End quote ---
The Siglent SSA3000X-R can do S11 and S21 measurement using two ports. It will not do S22 or S12 as only the one port can transmit. You will therefore have to switch the ports manually to get those done.
--- End quote ---
In other words, the Siglent SSA3000X-R is just a T/R VNA. So it doesn't qualify as a full 2 port VNA.
TimFox:
Two useful reference books about the previous generation of swept-spectrum SAs with digital control and analog processing (ca. 1990) with examples from Tektronix.
(1) M Engelson Modern Spectrum Analyzer Measurements JMS, 1991; Practical uses.
(2) M Engelson Modern Spectrum Analyzer Theory and Applications Artech House, 1984; More mathematical background than (1).
baldurn:
--- Quote from: G0HZU on March 15, 2024, 08:23:50 pm ---
--- Quote from: baldurn on March 15, 2024, 07:49:15 pm ---
--- Quote from: G0HZU on March 15, 2024, 07:19:13 pm ---So in this respect there isn't even a contest. The HP is a different class of VNA because it is a full 2 port VNA. The Siglent SA/VNA doesn't qualify for the contest because it's just a T/R VNA.
--- End quote ---
The Siglent SSA3000X-R can do S11 and S21 measurement using two ports. It will not do S22 or S12 as only the one port can transmit. You will therefore have to switch the ports manually to get those done.
--- End quote ---
In other words, the Siglent SSA3000X-R is just a T/R VNA. So it doesn't qualify as a full 2 port VNA.
--- End quote ---
The OP said he needed it to build an antenna. Besides you can do most things by switching the cables. It is just not as convenient. You can get all four S parameters.
I am not sure the claim that it will do worse measurements just because of only having one transmit port can be correct. But I have read that spectrum analyzers are build as SA first and the VNA part is tacked on trying to reuse circuits made for SA and therefore typically has worse performance. Unless OP can specify some requirements, I am going to assume the performance is more than good enough for what was described.
Siglent does have a device for 2 and 4 ports VNA with all ports equal. It is the SNA5000A but it is over budget even for the cheapest option. This does include a SA option and in this case it is the opposite of the SSA3000X-R: The SNA5000A is VNA first and SA second. Does seem to lack the protocol decodes and the RT option, which they are selling, does seem to be missing in the manual.
joeqsmith:
--- Quote from: baldurn on March 16, 2024, 01:22:38 am ---It is just not as convenient.
--- End quote ---
Missing the more advanced error corrections.
G0HZU:
--- Quote ---baldurn: I am not sure the claim that it will do worse measurements just because of only having one transmit port can be correct. But I have read that spectrum analyzers are build as SA first and the VNA part is tacked on trying to reuse circuits made for SA and therefore typically has worse performance. Unless OP can specify some requirements, I am going to assume the performance is more than good enough for what was described.
--- End quote ---
Have a look through this doc
https://www.kirkbymicrowave.co.uk/Support/Links/application-notes/HP-Agilent-Keysight/Keysight-Applying-Error-Correction-to-Network-Analyzer-Measurements_5965-7709E.pdf
The first couple of pages show how much better a full two port calibration is. See figure 1 that shows a full two port cal vs the response cal. The response cal has a lot of ripple on it. However, the ripple can sometimes be a lot worse than this.
It is possible to use external attenuators on the ports to improve a T/R VNA when measuring S21 and S12, I did this for many years using an old HP 8714B T/R VNA. It is very clunky to do this, especially if trying for all four s-parameters. I did this for many years until I upgraded to a more capable VNA.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version