Author Topic: Scope/Equipment Recommendation for Power Electronics (PE) Person  (Read 706 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Vancouver_KidTopic starter

  • Newbie
  • Posts: 7
  • Country: ca
Hi All,

I'm a PE who's starting to slowly build up my lab. I'm wanting a scope that is suited for PE applications (AC-DC or DC-DC). I'm not really familiar with all the scope brands out there so, with me giving some requirements/specifications I'm hoping the community can help suggest some options given:
  • $1000 CAD top end
  • I work with fundenmental frequencies of less than 500kHz
  • Would like bode plot
  • A high point count FFT (given the price range/class)
  • Ability to get some power analysis tools
  • 12-bit ADC
  • Serial/standard communication protocols, I2C, SPI, UART, USB, RS232/485, low speed stuff. No mipi buses here...
  • I would like to be able to capture SiC/GaN transition times, but, that may be asking too much given the price limitation. Thoughts?
  • Waveform capture rate, memory depth, sampling rate, I don't know what would be considered best in class these days given the price range but seeing some options would be great
  • Some suggestions for high voltage diff probes given the frequencies
  • The stuff I work on will most likely be 450VDC or less, that number is being driven by PFC output spec's
  • What rogowski coils are people using for TO220's (between the legs)? or

My own research for scopes led to here: https://siglentna.com/digital-oscilloscopes/sds800x-hd-digital-storage-oscilloscope/

It is very enticing to see the SDS804X HD and how it can be upgraded to the 200MHz version, although even when reading the instructions, I'm a bit confused. For $614 CAD and upgrading to a 200MHz version, the closest Rigol competitor I think would be the DHO924, but that's closer to $950 CAD. Would love to hear more of your opinions between the two given what I'm looking for and also the application. Features I haven't mentioned, etc.


Looking forward to the help and chatting about some options.

Cheers
 

Offline tautech

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 29813
  • Country: nz
  • Taupaki Technologies Ltd. Siglent Distributor NZ.
    • Taupaki Technologies Ltd.
Re: Scope/Equipment Recommendation for Power Electronics (PE) Person
« Reply #1 on: December 01, 2024, 10:59:48 pm »
Hi All,

I'm a PE who's starting to slowly build up my lab. I'm wanting a scope that is suited for PE applications (AC-DC or DC-DC). I'm not really familiar with all the scope brands out there so, with me giving some requirements/specifications I'm hoping the community can help suggest some options given:
  • $1000 CAD top end
  • I work with fundenmental frequencies of less than 500kHz
  • Would like bode plot
  • A high point count FFT (given the price range/class)
  • Ability to get some power analysis tools
  • 12-bit ADC
  • Serial/standard communication protocols, I2C, SPI, UART, USB, RS232/485, low speed stuff. No mipi buses here...
  • I would like to be able to capture SiC/GaN transition times, but, that may be asking too much given the price limitation. Thoughts?
  • Waveform capture rate, memory depth, sampling rate, I don't know what would be considered best in class these days given the price range but seeing some options would be great
  • Some suggestions for high voltage diff probes given the frequencies
  • The stuff I work on will most likely be 450VDC or less, that number is being driven by PFC output spec's
  • What rogowski coils are people using for TO220's (between the legs)? or

My own research for scopes led to here: https://siglentna.com/digital-oscilloscopes/sds800x-hd-digital-storage-oscilloscope/

It is very enticing to see the SDS804X HD and how it can be upgraded to the 200MHz version, although even when reading the instructions, I'm a bit confused. For $614 CAD and upgrading to a 200MHz version, the closest Rigol competitor I think would be the DHO924, but that's closer to $950 CAD. Would love to hear more of your opinions between the two given what I'm looking for and also the application. Features I haven't mentioned, etc.


Looking forward to the help and chatting about some options.

Cheers
Sound choice.  :-+

A little on the PA option here:
https://www.eevblog.com/forum/testgear/sds804x-hd-vs-sds814x-hd/msg5385836/#msg5385836
Avid Rabid Hobbyist.
Some stuff seen @ Siglent HQ cannot be shared.
 

Online Martin72

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 7019
  • Country: de
  • Testfield Technician
Re: Scope/Equipment Recommendation for Power Electronics (PE) Person
« Reply #2 on: December 01, 2024, 11:03:32 pm »
Hi,
If screen size is not important, the SDS800 series would be perfect for you.
Siglent's Bodeplot is very well implemented across all model series, and power analysis is also offered.
For the PA, a differential probe and a suitable current clamp are still required.

 
The following users thanked this post: Vancouver_Kid

Offline Vancouver_KidTopic starter

  • Newbie
  • Posts: 7
  • Country: ca
Re: Scope/Equipment Recommendation for Power Electronics (PE) Person
« Reply #3 on: December 02, 2024, 12:12:01 am »
Hi All,

I'm a PE who's starting to slowly build up my lab. I'm wanting a scope that is suited for PE applications (AC-DC or DC-DC). I'm not really familiar with all the scope brands out there so, with me giving some requirements/specifications I'm hoping the community can help suggest some options given:
  • $1000 CAD top end
  • I work with fundenmental frequencies of less than 500kHz
  • Would like bode plot
  • A high point count FFT (given the price range/class)
  • Ability to get some power analysis tools
  • 12-bit ADC
  • Serial/standard communication protocols, I2C, SPI, UART, USB, RS232/485, low speed stuff. No mipi buses here...
  • I would like to be able to capture SiC/GaN transition times, but, that may be asking too much given the price limitation. Thoughts?
  • Waveform capture rate, memory depth, sampling rate, I don't know what would be considered best in class these days given the price range but seeing some options would be great
  • Some suggestions for high voltage diff probes given the frequencies
  • The stuff I work on will most likely be 450VDC or less, that number is being driven by PFC output spec's
  • What rogowski coils are people using for TO220's (between the legs)? or

My own research for scopes led to here: https://siglentna.com/digital-oscilloscopes/sds800x-hd-digital-storage-oscilloscope/

It is very enticing to see the SDS804X HD and how it can be upgraded to the 200MHz version, although even when reading the instructions, I'm a bit confused. For $614 CAD and upgrading to a 200MHz version, the closest Rigol competitor I think would be the DHO924, but that's closer to $950 CAD. Would love to hear more of your opinions between the two given what I'm looking for and also the application. Features I haven't mentioned, etc.


Looking forward to the help and chatting about some options.

Cheers
Sound choice.  :-+

A little on the PA option here:
https://www.eevblog.com/forum/testgear/sds804x-hd-vs-sds814x-hd/msg5385836/#msg5385836

Hi, okay good to know I was on the right track. Those two scope brands are ones I'm familiar with, and then there's the more premium brands at work we all most likely use.

What about these guys: GW Instek, Micsig, Owon

I've seen/used some Micsig stuff and for PE's it can be helpful when you make the source the internal battery rather than wall plug, but I haven't really been able to narrow something down within my budget. Know of any models?

GW instek and Owon I see pop up, but never met anyone who uses them so I have zero insight into whether there okay or not. Thoughts?
 

Online nctnico

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 28429
  • Country: nl
    • NCT Developments
Re: Scope/Equipment Recommendation for Power Electronics (PE) Person
« Reply #4 on: December 02, 2024, 12:20:58 am »
GW Instek and Micsig make good equipment but not for bottom of the barrel prices. Typically their equipment just works as expected out of the box without needing endless firmware updates.

Yokogawa seems to focus a lot on oscilloscopes for power electronics. But again, way outside your budget.

Owon OTOH is a bottom the barrel brand which might be dissapointing. Oscilloscopes require complex firmware and need quite an investment in developing time & money to get it right.

« Last Edit: December 02, 2024, 12:27:26 am by nctnico »
There are small lies, big lies and then there is what is on the screen of your oscilloscope.
 

Offline tautech

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 29813
  • Country: nz
  • Taupaki Technologies Ltd. Siglent Distributor NZ.
    • Taupaki Technologies Ltd.
Re: Scope/Equipment Recommendation for Power Electronics (PE) Person
« Reply #5 on: December 02, 2024, 12:26:51 am »
Hi All,

I'm a PE who's starting to slowly build up my lab. I'm wanting a scope that is suited for PE applications (AC-DC or DC-DC). I'm not really familiar with all the scope brands out there so, with me giving some requirements/specifications I'm hoping the community can help suggest some options given:
  • $1000 CAD top end
  • I work with fundenmental frequencies of less than 500kHz
  • Would like bode plot
  • A high point count FFT (given the price range/class)
  • Ability to get some power analysis tools
  • 12-bit ADC
  • Serial/standard communication protocols, I2C, SPI, UART, USB, RS232/485, low speed stuff. No mipi buses here...
  • I would like to be able to capture SiC/GaN transition times, but, that may be asking too much given the price limitation. Thoughts?
  • Waveform capture rate, memory depth, sampling rate, I don't know what would be considered best in class these days given the price range but seeing some options would be great
  • Some suggestions for high voltage diff probes given the frequencies
  • The stuff I work on will most likely be 450VDC or less, that number is being driven by PFC output spec's
  • What rogowski coils are people using for TO220's (between the legs)? or

My own research for scopes led to here: https://siglentna.com/digital-oscilloscopes/sds800x-hd-digital-storage-oscilloscope/

It is very enticing to see the SDS804X HD and how it can be upgraded to the 200MHz version, although even when reading the instructions, I'm a bit confused. For $614 CAD and upgrading to a 200MHz version, the closest Rigol competitor I think would be the DHO924, but that's closer to $950 CAD. Would love to hear more of your opinions between the two given what I'm looking for and also the application. Features I haven't mentioned, etc.


Looking forward to the help and chatting about some options.

Cheers
Sound choice.  :-+

A little on the PA option here:
https://www.eevblog.com/forum/testgear/sds804x-hd-vs-sds814x-hd/msg5385836/#msg5385836

Hi, okay good to know I was on the right track. Those two scope brands are ones I'm familiar with, and then there's the more premium brands at work we all most likely use.

What about these guys: GW Instek, Micsig, Owon

I've seen/used some Micsig stuff and for PE's it can be helpful when you make the source the internal battery rather than wall plug, but I haven't really been able to narrow something down within my budget. Know of any models?

GW instek and Owon I see pop up, but never met anyone who uses them so I have zero insight into whether there okay or not. Thoughts?
That's the issue but with all the features you need SDS800X HD has the same as the higher priced Siglent models all the way to the 6 GHz SDS7000A.
They share the same GUI which makes SDS800X HD models attractive as a cheap sounding board before investing in the $ $ models with more features.

Don't underestimate these cheap little platforms.....
Avid Rabid Hobbyist.
Some stuff seen @ Siglent HQ cannot be shared.
 

Offline Vancouver_KidTopic starter

  • Newbie
  • Posts: 7
  • Country: ca
Re: Scope/Equipment Recommendation for Power Electronics (PE) Person
« Reply #6 on: December 03, 2024, 04:26:33 pm »
Hi All,

I'm a PE who's starting to slowly build up my lab. I'm wanting a scope that is suited for PE applications (AC-DC or DC-DC). I'm not really familiar with all the scope brands out there so, with me giving some requirements/specifications I'm hoping the community can help suggest some options given:
  • $1000 CAD top end
  • I work with fundenmental frequencies of less than 500kHz
  • Would like bode plot
  • A high point count FFT (given the price range/class)
  • Ability to get some power analysis tools
  • 12-bit ADC
  • Serial/standard communication protocols, I2C, SPI, UART, USB, RS232/485, low speed stuff. No mipi buses here...
  • I would like to be able to capture SiC/GaN transition times, but, that may be asking too much given the price limitation. Thoughts?
  • Waveform capture rate, memory depth, sampling rate, I don't know what would be considered best in class these days given the price range but seeing some options would be great
  • Some suggestions for high voltage diff probes given the frequencies
  • The stuff I work on will most likely be 450VDC or less, that number is being driven by PFC output spec's
  • What rogowski coils are people using for TO220's (between the legs)? or

My own research for scopes led to here: https://siglentna.com/digital-oscilloscopes/sds800x-hd-digital-storage-oscilloscope/

It is very enticing to see the SDS804X HD and how it can be upgraded to the 200MHz version, although even when reading the instructions, I'm a bit confused. For $614 CAD and upgrading to a 200MHz version, the closest Rigol competitor I think would be the DHO924, but that's closer to $950 CAD. Would love to hear more of your opinions between the two given what I'm looking for and also the application. Features I haven't mentioned, etc.


Looking forward to the help and chatting about some options.

Cheers
Sound choice.  :-+

A little on the PA option here:
https://www.eevblog.com/forum/testgear/sds804x-hd-vs-sds814x-hd/msg5385836/#msg5385836

Hi, okay good to know I was on the right track. Those two scope brands are ones I'm familiar with, and then there's the more premium brands at work we all most likely use.

What about these guys: GW Instek, Micsig, Owon

I've seen/used some Micsig stuff and for PE's it can be helpful when you make the source the internal battery rather than wall plug, but I haven't really been able to narrow something down within my budget. Know of any models?

GW instek and Owon I see pop up, but never met anyone who uses them so I have zero insight into whether there okay or not. Thoughts?
That's the issue but with all the features you need SDS800X HD has the same as the higher priced Siglent models all the way to the 6 GHz SDS7000A.
They share the same GUI which makes SDS800X HD models attractive as a cheap sounding board before investing in the $ $ models with more features.

Don't underestimate these cheap little platforms.....

Could you use such a scope for doing pre-compliance say for FCC part 15B, for instance? You wouldn't be able to visualize anything related to quasi-peak, right? Is the AVG the same AVG on a spectrum analyzer? I've never really used FFT's on scopes before, so I don't know much about how they compare to an actual benchtop spectrum analyzer. Would be great if you could speak about whether you could get away with doing some pre-compliance work, say conducted EMI from a LISN? The lack of a 50ohm input I imagine would be an issue..
 

Offline Smokey

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 3046
  • Country: us
  • Not An Expert
Re: Scope/Equipment Recommendation for Power Electronics (PE) Person
« Reply #7 on: December 03, 2024, 06:00:29 pm »
Hi All,

I'm a PE who's starting to slowly build up my lab. I'm wanting a scope that is suited for PE applications (AC-DC or DC-DC).
...

Just a heads up, "PE" is usually used to mean "Professional Engineer" as in the license. 
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulation_and_licensure_in_engineering
I've never heard a power guy call himself a PE to refer to "power electronics person" (and I'm sort of a power electronics guy).
 

Offline tautech

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 29813
  • Country: nz
  • Taupaki Technologies Ltd. Siglent Distributor NZ.
    • Taupaki Technologies Ltd.
Re: Scope/Equipment Recommendation for Power Electronics (PE) Person
« Reply #8 on: December 03, 2024, 07:28:59 pm »
Could you use such a scope for doing pre-compliance say for FCC part 15B, for instance? You wouldn't be able to visualize anything related to quasi-peak, right? Is the AVG the same AVG on a spectrum analyzer? I've never really used FFT's on scopes before, so I don't know much about how they compare to an actual benchtop spectrum analyzer. Would be great if you could speak about whether you could get away with doing some pre-compliance work, say conducted EMI from a LISN? The lack of a 50ohm input I imagine would be an issue..
No.
25 MHz max for SAG1021I.
It doesn't pair with FFT like a TG in a SA.

Many questions of how FFT works can be found in this thread:
https://www.eevblog.com/forum/testgear/sds800x-hd-review-demonstration-thread/
Avid Rabid Hobbyist.
Some stuff seen @ Siglent HQ cannot be shared.
 
The following users thanked this post: Vancouver_Kid

Online Martin72

  • Super Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 7019
  • Country: de
  • Testfield Technician
Re: Scope/Equipment Recommendation for Power Electronics (PE) Person
« Reply #9 on: December 03, 2024, 09:51:55 pm »
What about these guys: GW Instek, Micsig, Owon

I've seen/used some Micsig stuff and for PE's it can be helpful when you make the source the internal battery rather than wall plug, but I haven't really been able to narrow something down within my budget. Know of any models?

GW instek and Owon I see pop up, but never met anyone who uses them so I have zero insight into whether there okay or not. Thoughts?

If you couldn't spend much money, 10...15 years ago the cheap China brands were the only alternative to the well-known professional brands.
Mention should be made of Hantek, Uni-T, Liliput Owon, Rigol, Siglent, GW Instek.

At that time, they were a bit of a grab bag; sometimes the product was good, sometimes not, or mostly not.
Time has passed and some have developed into respectable manufacturers.
Others, on the other hand, are still providers of grab bags, presumably because they only resell and do not develop anything themselves.
Personally, I would give Hantek, Owon and Uni-T a wide berth when it comes to oscilloscopes.
Rigol and Siglent are now well-known manufacturers that, in addition to high-priced products, have not forgotten their “roots” and still offer affordable oscilloscopes.
Whereby siglent has a clear advantage in terms of professionalism and support, even with the cheaper models.
I think GW instek is an interesting brand.
I only know them for frequency generators and milliohm meters, so I can't form an opinion about their scopes.
The same applies to Micsig, a relatively young brand.
I only know them for their probes and current clamps.
That still works for them a bit like a grab bag.
I can't say anything about their scopes, because, as with GW instek, I haven't been able to test any yet, and I don't say anything about them.
 
The following users thanked this post: Vancouver_Kid

Offline 1audio

  • Frequent Contributor
  • **
  • Posts: 317
  • Country: us
Re: Scope/Equipment Recommendation for Power Electronics (PE) Person
« Reply #10 on: December 04, 2024, 03:17:26 am »
If you are talking about power as in motor controls, variable speed drives etc. then you need something that will be safe to use around those. I would recomend a Tek THS720P or similar which can be had for a pretty reasonable price https://www.ebay.com/itm/276708270659?_skw=ths720&itmmeta=01JE7TM4DXWT12V3NW1PRA3JSW&hash=item406d192243:g:L6oAAOSwWldjQpaO&itmprp=enc%3AAQAJAAAA4HoV3kP08IDx%2BKZ9MfhVJKkQqxdekFV%2F7Vnw4WxJ44ysTqN4zLskY6VzOFzgic8bmbLZCRq7RI9f3X71InPay62VQYlIMKpVjGPsp4gT9888VCKs3rcTDVm3MvD9yt83g6y1l79G6wHDnXTBsNjy2DXaQIgRROOzi1%2F0Hqnu9%2BAQpHzeHjlVIdSw1KvFjq00hkdqwthOOtCusUvSIVH8o5rMgFcL0ocmA8dxBfELu1KCZP2NHeMbjeTg5Qk%2Ferselh9yeb2PZLUlZjhytcEhm8D6iP32B7PduYRjKq%2FcTKCQ%7Ctkp%3ABFBMjsfQ-vFk. They have fully isolated inputs that you can hang on various phases safely and the P variant has other features useful for AC power like harmonic analysis. There is a thred here on how to convert a 720A to a 720P.

LISN's are expensive even on eBay. More than a decent scope. Maybe you can build one but I'm not sure how to validate a DIY LISN. Precompliance involves a lot of stuff to check. Its facinating and interesting to do the measurements but probably not cost effective to get all the stuff. And time consuming if from eBay and hamfests.
 
The following users thanked this post: Vancouver_Kid


Share me

Digg  Facebook  SlashDot  Delicious  Technorati  Twitter  Google  Yahoo
Smf