I would get the used 2000i assuming it looks to be in good shape, no question. It's still very compact and light weight and it's double the power for less money. Sooner or later you'll probably want the extra power. For me a EU2000i is enough to power my whole house with some care. I feed both sides of the panel in parallel through a transfer switch from the generator output so all of the 120V loads in the house are powered while the high power 240V loads are not and it works great. I can run my gas furnace, internet router, lights, gas stove/oven, dishwasher, it feels almost normal, just requires some care not to run two large loads at once.