I think it's a great idea. Most of the PCB vendor forums are sucky:
- Altium has much useful info in their old forum, and in Live, but you have to be a subscriber, and Altium live is awkward.
- Eagle has newgroups, which is something of an outdated format, although there is a conduit to a forum format. There's also an Eagle yahoo group. Yahoo groups are better than nothing, but not great.
- Pulsonix has a yahoo group, which seems used and maintained by users, but it's yahoo, which is not great.
- EDAboard has a PCB section, but it's pretty general, and the signal to noise ratio there is very low.
- The free packages (kicad, geda) have, I believe, mailing lists but no great central forums.
As a user of Altium, I'd love to see an altium forum here. As an ex-user of Eagle, and a follower of eagle and pulsonix, It would be nice to keep tabs on what capabilities are developing in other software. It would also be nice to peek in on those using the free packages as well.
When I'm in a PCB phase, I frequent the Altium forums, but otherwise, my attendance drops off. However, I've been browsing this board more and more. I imagine it's the same for others. I'd certainly check in on an altium forum, once I'm here.
Dave