FTDI driver kills fake FTDI FT232??

[zapta]

The ones that had a problem already were risking their motors with NASTY $20 cables built with fake parts. If the FTID drivers brick your cable you know you had a piece of shit built with fake parts of unknown quality and origin which ought to to be replaced.

Your answer is to replace all the cables with something using another part because the other part makes it harder to know when you have a piece of shit built with fake parts.

The main risk is future FTDI actions. Staying away from anything related to FTDI reduces the risk. FTDI became its own enemy. This is the brand suicide Dave mentioned in his video. It's that simple.

[Fungus]

The ones that had a problem already were risking their motors with NASTY $20 cables built with fake parts. If the FTID drivers brick your cable you know you had a piece of shit built with fake parts of unknown quality and origin which ought to to be replaced.

Your answer is to replace all the cables with something using another part because the other part makes it harder to know when you have a piece of shit built with fake parts.

Back under your bridge, troll. We're not playing...

[Rufus]

The main risk is future FTDI actions. Staying away from anything related to FTDI reduces the risk.

There is no risk if you are not using fake parts - so as I keep saying if you want to get away with using fake crap of unknown quality and origin then avoiding FTDI parts is a good idea.

If you don't want to be using fake crap of unknown quality and origin then you have more reason to use FTDI parts now than you did before the recent driver release.

[edavid]

Re: Rufus:

There's no point in addressing Rufus, he is read-only.

To tell if a chip is faked/refurbished, simply look at its marking. Reputable ic vendors will use laser beam to print their markings, while other vendors may use old school silk printer. Also, even if some small companies do have laser markers, they won't have the best ones. Their markings may not be as "crispy" as genuine ones. You can always buy one sample from digikey, or download a high resolution picture of a genuine chip, and compare it with your samples.

If you read the earlier posts, you will see that the genuine FTDI parts have printed markings, while at least some of the fake ones are laser marked 

[zapta]

[There is no risk if you are not using fake parts - so as I keep saying if you want to get away with using fake crap of unknown quality and origin then avoiding FTDI parts is a good idea.

If you don't want to be using fake crap of unknown quality and origin then you have more reason to use FTDI parts now than you did before the recent driver release.

With ideal supply chain you are right. With real world supply chain FTDI is risky because units will pass QC and will later fail in the field when FTDI will escalate their counter measures.

For designers, the practical thing to do is keeping FTDI out.  It's that simple.

[Rufus]

There is not a single engineer wants to use fake chips, but shamely, their bosses may.

Sure and when FTDI come out with an effective if somewhat brutal method of detecting fakes a proportion of 'engineers' here scream "Oh shit I didn't want to know" and I should take measures so I won't know in the future.

[Rufus]

Rufus is not a *troll*, if you look at his postings, he is actually a very intelligent person and a competent engineer.

Now I will have to go back through my old posts to find something I can use to dispute that assertion

[dannyf]

there *ARE* some FTDI paid trolls on this thread.

You think they are and they are are two different things.

[dannyf]

But when an otherwise intelligent person is making illogical arguments to support a position, then you know that there is a hidden agenda.

What's logical or not is highly subjective. What's illogical to you may be perfectly logical to somebody else, and vice versa.

Either way, it is best not to impart bad intentions on people who disagree with you.

[Rick Law]

there *ARE* some FTDI paid trolls on this thread.

You think they are and they are are two different things.

Perhaps.  But when an otherwise intelligent person is making illogical arguments to support a position, then you know that there is a hidden agenda.  As an example, just listen to some USA politicians sometime with your ears open, when they are trying to convince you that something that *is* is not, or that something that *isn't* is....

re: "intelligent person is making illogical arguments to support a position, then you know that there is a hidden agenda."

May be there is a hidden agenda, but may be not.   We all on occasion dig our heels in.  At times, our heels got dug in so far it became a "reflex instinct" to fight to the finish...

Many of us here are in occupation with moments of high pressure and/or long hours with excessive stress.  Such condition often cause some to be irritable, or short tempered, or stubbornly unreasonable at times.

We all have our stubborn moments...

[zapta]

May be there is a hidden agenda, but may be not.   We all on occasion dig our heels in.  At times, our heels got dug in so far it became a "reflex instinct" to fight to the finish...

Many of us here are in occupation with moments of high pressure and/or long hours with excessive stress.  Such condition often cause some to be irritable, or short tempered, or stubbornly unreasonable at times.

We all have our stubborn moments...

I strongly disagree!

[a210210200]

Wow, that philosophy wouldn't last two minutes in a proper customer-support organization. How astonishingly clueless about the end-user support world.

Please elaborate on how you think the entire all industries all fields of work end user support world should work. Does everyone get a personal IT support person standing by their side to guide them through the terribly complex process of pointing, clicking, and typing into this strange box the strange person calls a computer?

Which by the way if you want I can do it for you personally for free online to fix the FTDI PID issues if you have any. In IT support if the person is at an ends of their ability then yes people take over but you shouldn't hand hold 100% of the time and must adapt to the situation and person your talking to. For an IT group fixing things like this is peanuts compared to a bad windows update that wasn't caught in deployment testing which can cause many more problems.

I LOVE this thread!!!  I have to 'disappear' from the net for a weekend due to a 'far more important' hobby of mine (drag racing)...  Not only do I come back to find another whole BATCH of politically induced BULLSHIT from 'the paid troll', I also had to waste several HOURS 'fixing' the data-logger connectivity of several VERY high end drag racers (who now consider me to be an absolute 'I.T. deity'...  Go figure!!!).  Naturally, after having remedied their issues, I explained (impartially? Yeah right, they KNOW me better than that!!!) the reasons why their time proven systems had suddenly turned into custard.  The 'news' spread through the venue like an Santa Ana bushfire and they all want me to build them a new USB-RS232C cable that will take the big FTDI question totally out of the equation!  Even the Top Fuellers who already had GENUINE FTDI chips in their systems.....  (Racepak and RPM seem to supply a 'custom' VID / PID on their FTDI equipped cables as do many others).  It's simply not worth them 'risking' a $200k motor on some NASTY $20 cable!
I probably SHOULD be thanking FTDI for the extra business, but in reality, I am NOT an EE...  I just 'hit keys' and electronics is merely a hobby.
Perhaps FTDI needs to mix a bit more Ammonium Nitrate into their Nitromethane next time so they can 'go out in style'....  OKLAHOMA style...
Anyway, I have a bunch more in this thread (from the 'paid trolls')....  Might be more posts from me real soon

Wait wouldn't the fact that your tricking people into paying you money by taking advantage of the news be the very definition of a paid troll? You have a clear conflict of interest in that your directly benefiting by your own admission.

A custom VID/PID part would not be affected by this PID change issue so your in fact lying to your customers to induce them to give you work they don't need done. This is beyond unethical.

[a210210200]

Rufus is not a *troll*, if you look at his postings, he is actually a very intelligent person and a competent engineer.  To me at least, he seems to like a good fight, and in general seems to engage in contrary thinking to the rest of the forum on many occasions.  There is nothing wrong with that, and it keeps all of our minds sharp as a bonus.  BUT-- there *ARE* some FTDI paid trolls on this thread.  I will leave it up to you to ferret them out...  Look for things like: supporting FTDI's actions [of releasing a driver containing trojan malware] no matter how flawed the logic; and: not having any other postings on any other thread except for this one...  Good hunting!

I think it has been shown that you're an outright liar so I wouldn't put much stock in your claims,

https://www.eevblog.com/forum/reviews/ftdi-driver-kills-fake-ftdi-ft232/msg541760/#msg541760

Edit: grammar corrected (your > you're), minor error (a > an)

[Rick Law]

Rufus is not a *troll*, if you look at his postings, he is actually a very intelligent person and a competent engineer.  To me at least, he seems to like a good fight, and in general seems to engage in contrary thinking to the rest of the forum on many occasions.  There is nothing wrong with that, and it keeps all of our minds sharp as a bonus.  BUT-- there *ARE* some FTDI paid trolls on this thread.  I will leave it up to you to ferret them out...  Look for things like: supporting FTDI's actions [of releasing a driver containing trojan malware] no matter how flawed the logic; and: not having any other postings on any other thread except for this one...  Good hunting!

I think it has been shown that your a outright liar so I wouldn't put much stock in your claims,

https://www.eevblog.com/forum/reviews/ftdi-driver-kills-fake-ftdi-ft232/msg541760/#msg541760

Come now, digging your heels in is one thing, lets avoid getting too close to personal attack.

If there was indeed an inconsistent statement made, one could point it out and ask for an explanation.

Rick

[AlfBaz]

... x 158

I'm curious, but not so much that I want to read through every one of your posts in this thread (curiously this thread alone). Have you, or can you categorically deny any affiliation with FTDI?

[a210210200]

Come now, digging your heels in is one thing, lets avoid getting too close to personal attack.

If there was indeed an inconsistent statement made, one could point it out and ask for an explanation.

Rick

It is just a completely factual statement or if you don't think that just tit-for-tat.

A personal attack would be like in direct response to my reply,
"You are obviously a "shill" for FTDI." which both implies that I'm somehow being paid to write my opinion which I find ethically abhorrent and highly offensive that someone would claim that and then have the gall to say he did not later saying that it was proof again that I was (assuming no one read far enough back to top that off).

[zapta]

I think it has been shown that your a outright liar so I wouldn't put much stock in your claims,

And I think you are an FTDI paid operative that was sent here to distract us from the real trolls. Show us your bank statement if it's not true.

Seriously, people have the right to have different opinions. Otherwise it would be boring here. No need to go personal. Even if FTDI has trolls here, so what, if you don't agree with the opinion they express don't adopt them.

[Lightages]

Rufus is not a *troll*, if you look at his postings, he is actually a very intelligent person and a competent engineer.  To me at least, he seems to like a good fight, and in general seems to engage in contrary thinking to the rest of the forum on many occasions.  There is nothing wrong with that, and it keeps all of our minds sharp as a bonus.  BUT-- there *ARE* some FTDI paid trolls on this thread.  I will leave it up to you to ferret them out...  Look for things like: supporting FTDI's actions [of releasing a driver containing trojan malware] no matter how flawed the logic; and: not having any other postings on any other thread except for this one...  Good hunting!

I think it has been shown that your a outright liar so I wouldn't put much stock in your claims,

https://www.eevblog.com/forum/reviews/ftdi-driver-kills-fake-ftdi-ft232/msg541760/#msg541760

It is very ironic the link you refer to shows you critisizing another for poor grammar when you say here:

I think it has been shown that your a outright liar so I wouldn't put much stock in your claims,

Please stop your personal attacks as it is against the forum rules and reduces your reputation here. I also must say that I believe you are trolling but I could be wrong. It is just that it seems you joined just to defend FTDI.

[a210210200]

... x 158

I'm curious, but not so much that I want to read through every one of your posts in this thread (curiously this thread alone). Have you, or can you categorically deny any affiliation with FTDI?

Yes I do categorically deny any affiliation with FTDI, I'm an employee at the University Of British Columbia and I designed a few boards with FTDI chips and that is it just as many others have here and saw the fuss after finishing another project and decided to jump over to the board after catching up on youtube subscription uploads.

If you are at UBC pm me and we can arrange a meeting and I can give you a tour of where I work. I don't think it is good for internet security reasons to go posting a mountain of information.

Also this is just the main thread I'm sitting on and it is not in fact true that this is the only thread I comment on, I'm a new user and the first thread I jump into is usually going to start with a bang. I deliver quality service which in comments means a whole wall of words it is just how I write in general.

[a210210200]

I think it has been shown that your a outright liar so I wouldn't put much stock in your claims,

And I think you are an FTDI paid operative that was sent here to distract us from the real trolls. Show us your bank statement if it's not true.

Seriously, people have the right to have different opinions. Otherwise it would be boring here. No need to go personal. Even if FTDI has trolls here, so what, if you don't agree with the opinion they express don't adopt them.

Seriously your going to ask me to post my bank statement that is pretty odd request to ask. No one should post that kind of information to a public forum PM me and I can meet in person if you want at my place of work. People do have the right to have an opinion but when they start claiming things like you are it isn't opinion when they contradict themselves.

[a210210200]

Rufus is not a *troll*, if you look at his postings, he is actually a very intelligent person and a competent engineer.  To me at least, he seems to like a good fight, and in general seems to engage in contrary thinking to the rest of the forum on many occasions.  There is nothing wrong with that, and it keeps all of our minds sharp as a bonus.  BUT-- there *ARE* some FTDI paid trolls on this thread.  I will leave it up to you to ferret them out...  Look for things like: supporting FTDI's actions [of releasing a driver containing trojan malware] no matter how flawed the logic; and: not having any other postings on any other thread except for this one...  Good hunting!

I think it has been shown that your a outright liar so I wouldn't put much stock in your claims,

https://www.eevblog.com/forum/reviews/ftdi-driver-kills-fake-ftdi-ft232/msg541760/#msg541760

It is very ironic the link you refer to shows you critisizing another for poor grammar when you say here:

I think it has been shown that your a outright liar so I wouldn't put much stock in your claims,

Please stop your personal attacks as it is against the forum rules and reduces your reputation here. I also must say that I believe you are trolling but I could be wrong. It is just that it seems you joined just to defend FTDI.

I don't think your reading it correctly I'm not criticizing the grammar I'm showing that he is making a highly contradictory statement by saying he never directly mentioned me when he did in fact have an entire post equating me to FTDI.

Edit: Grammar wars is just the flavor of the post the meat of it is his own quotes contradicting himself. Also there is a huge difference between defending a point of view and being paid sponsor to write a script. It is a highly personal attack to claim that someone is just a paid puppet.

[a210210200]

This post is a bit different because it is from another IP address which is a UBC workstation that I have remote access rights to for support and processing data remotely. So if any admin/mod wants to check it should resolve to UBC.

[free_electron]

wow. what a bunch of fanboi's here.

here is my view :

- I agree FTDI needs a slap on the wrist for delivering a driver that bricks stuff, that isn't theirs, deliberately.
- On the other hand: FTDI is perfectly allowed to refuse to let someone steal the fruit of their labour. USB has always been a pain in the butt to implement. They were the pioneers in making it simple. They just could have done it a bit differently (a popup saying the driver is incompatible with the attached device and refusing to connect. done . this would have people go to the device manufacturer requesting working drivers. so they can clean up their mess)

- i will happily continue using FTDI devices. they work. if all i need is a simple uart mode i may stuff in a silabs or cypres but most oftenly i use the MPSSE and bitbang functionality. NONE of the others have that.
- counterfeited parts are real. get your stuff from reputable source. if it tanks, go knock on their door : they will set it right.

just my 2 cents. you may disagree/ agree: i don't care. i just voiced my view.

[dannyf]

Seriously your going to ask me to post my bank statement that is pretty odd request to ask. No one should post that kind of information to a public forum PM me and I can meet in person if you want at my place of work.

I wouldn't even respond to that kind of crazy demand. Tell them to go pound sand.

[zapta]

Seriously your going to ask me to post my bank statement that is pretty odd request to ask. No one should post that kind of information to a public forum PM me and I can meet in person if you want at my place of work.

I wouldn't even respond to that kind of crazy demand. Tell them to go pound sand.

It's a sure way to detect forum trolls, just like the witches drowning test.