Add paraffin wax and some plastics to your list. Higher specific heat capacity than granite and lower thermal conductivity.
Yes, there are some plastics in the right ballpark, and yes they are much easier to work, but polymers as a rule, cannot be bought in a usable shape.
You can get them as pipes, sticks, granules, sheets, foils, tapes, but not as a solid 5cm cube.
If you find something 5cm thick, it is likely to be at least 40cm on the two other dimensions, and weigh so much the postman will hate you forever.
(Cutting 5cm thick polymer takes a really good wide-toothed high-speed circular saw. Too low speed or too thin-toothed and the friction will melt the polymer and your saw will get stuck. Do not ask me how I know this :-)
All that said: Any lump of high density polymer (HDPE, ABS etc.) will give more stable temperature than what we usually see on pictures here.
But ask your wife first: There is 22% chance she have a pair of geologic candlelight holders she never uses.