When combing components, to meet a requested replacement value I'd like to know the correct way of determining whether the replacement value is within spec.
https://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/how-about-combining-some-components/
The requested target is something like: 987,6 Ω ± 300 mΩ
The replacement value could be something like: 987,8 Ω ± 200 mΩ
Is there a standardized way of determining whether the latter is within spec, with ..٪ probability.
I've done some research myself, but I don't expect to get a solid answer using Google.
It would be great if someone knows of a method, better than taking the uncertainty bounds of both and check if the requested bounds are fully overlapping.
I've edited the uncertainty from 987,6 Ω ± 3 mΩ to 987,6 Ω ± 300 mΩ
and 987,8 Ω ± 2 mΩ to 987,8 Ω ± 200 mΩ
I had to read this over a couple of times, because I couldn't really follow.
But I can give an answer of using a couple of methods.
One is the theoretical way to get you in the right direction.
This is called relative error estimation based on partial derivatives.
Sometimes also called linear approximations with the chain rule I believe?
My apologies, I am a bit lost in translation, since I learned this stuff in my native language, see pic I found as an example.
Basically what you do, is you make an equation of the circuit in question, derive all the variables and take the absolute, multiply them with the expected error and sum all of these.
The downside of this method is that it expects that the error will be linear, in reality this isn't always true obviously. *
If we are talking about probabilities, one needs to use standard error as well as the standard deviation.
Although these two look very similar (and A LOT of people mix them up!), they are VERY different!
One will give you a number how precise you know the average, the other one will give a number of the spread across the samples.
Using 2 or 3 sigma is enough for most general electronics, in science they mostly use 4 or 5 sigma (or more)
That being said, in general paralleling resistors usually results in not changing the relative error.
While putting them in series results in doubling (or summing) them.
* Since the behavior and tolerance of most electronics is pretty tight (< 2%) and for devices like resistors pretty predictable, this isn't really an issue.
It will be a much bigger issue for other variables (non electronics) with a relative error around 20-30% or that kind of order of magnitude.