Ouch. Harsh. But thankyou for giving me the oportunity to cut you to shreds.
1) I just spent a few years in FPGA distribution. I've been lucky to see a LOT of products and work with a lot of design teams. I can say the follow with confidence that: no one does a Cyclone board with components on both sides. Cheap chip + expensive assembly = not make sense much.
Low cost means getting it done on a single sided assembly. I have seen plenty of Arria, Spartan 6 and even a Virtex-5 layout that are single sided in real manufacture, in real volume. You've got to rememer that a via is a narrow, resistive, inductive path and decoupling on the bottom side is not a lot better than decoupling a top side plane. That's why vias get backdrilled on RF boards. A plane on the top side is actually a BETTER solution. Planes have very little inductance and form a better return path for currents, so are effective EMC shielding too. GND bounce occurs on traces, and vias, not planes. On an F256 package, you are also quite close to the ball - I would hesitate on a F780 package, but in fact I've seen it done there too.
2) USB Blaster - When you go to build your own board, you need to have one. So why would I load up the dev board with $30 of parts and testing that you can't re-use, when you can spend $50 but keep re-using it? Didn't appeal; went with flexibility and keeping it simple. If you are planning on never going to a custom PCB then yes - it is a $50 adder, you have a valid point there, but I want people to migrate their designs to PCBs one day - and having a module makes that really quite simple - especially when most shields come with EagleCAD files you can drop down. 2 Layer boards are so freeken cheap now that this is the way electronics should move. Less wires everywhere and $hit falling off a dev board; more nice simple, robust $50 2 layer boards with modules on them. Less likely to crash your prototype UAV.
What I'm thinking of doing is getting a USB-Blaster clone and bundling it with the boards. But I was waiting for feedback first. Thanks for the feedback.
3) DE2-115... it's $595... are you kidding me? And the peripherals are totally fixed and won't suite everyone. At least my board lets you swap the peripherals around, and there are 300+ shields. I'm not joking - have a look at the shield database shieldlist.org. Even the academic price on DE2-115 is $295. If you buy my board for $175, + postage + usb_blaster you're only up to $265, so you have money left for a shield. My board has DDR2 vs DDR, four times as much, twice as much SRAM, and have you tried to do anything with Terasic's code?
DE0_NANO is a better sell, but it's still $80 and it isn't a dev board. It's a module. If you compare it to our module: we are $20 cheaper minimum, has DDR2, more of it, more sram, an ATSHA204 crypto IC, more flash, and it's smaller with a more rugged finish. No fasteners. We're qualifying the module for pick and place use, and oven reflow too - so you have more options for low cost assmebly.
4) Rolling your own PCB is great, that's what we WANT to see more of, but we're trying to save you having to roll a board with 3x BGAs on it. That's a real bitch to get right by hand. Instead roll your own 2 layer board, but then use our module on it for $40~$60. Compare that to buying discreet parts from Digikey. Concentrate on your peripherals and your application specific circuits this way.
Copying a reference design is a great way to waste a couple of months.
5) The problem with selling a bare cyclone FPGA is that it needs a system around it and that's hard work. It's not an MCU. The point of a module is to put that system around it, and standardise the hardware so you can standardise the support. Now everyone can use the same templates, drivers, example projects, etc.
6) There are NO magic bullets, but we're at 28nm silicon now. 20nm is next year. It's driving cost down like crazy. These Cyclone IV FPGAs cost less now than a high end PIC (albeit not from Digikey). They're coming to general applications quickly, not just specialty niche work.
No, HDL is not easy to write, but Verilog is based on C, and SystemVerilog takes away all those trivialities associated with reg and wire. There are incremental improvements in every new Quartus release, and you can just download a Nios2 template and get on with it if you want.
I think that we're all going to have to be multi-lingual in the future. If you want to know a good languge to invest in - SystemVerilog is a great one with a big future. Stop living in a C bubble.
So do you want a loaner for a few weeks? Send me your address and I'll post you one.
[email protected] :-)